The Spanish Government was informed of the abovementioned observations by letter dated 6 September 1989, giving it notice to submit its comments within a one-month period. The Spanish authorities answered by telex of 20 October 1989, reaffirming their former observations submitted to the Commission in the sense of considering all the interventions rightful and compatible with the Treaty.
IV
On its examination of the public interventions in support of Magefesa, the Commission has verified to what extent those measures contain aid elements in the light of Articles 92 to 94 of the Treaty.
According to the information available to the Commission, the Spanish authorities decided the following interventions in relation to Magefesa - save otherwise indicated, all of them granted in 1986:
Loan guarantees
The governments of the autonomous Communities of the Basque Country, Cantabria and Andalusia have awarded to Magefesa, respectively: Pta 972 512 and 96 million worth of guarantees on bank loans.
Such interventions undoubtedly constitute an aid to Magefesa since they have enabled it to arrange credits to continue trading. These credits had been unlikely to obtain otherwise without the State guarantee given its serious financial difficulties.
Previous to the abovementioned grants, in 1985 the Government of Cantabria had awarded guarantees amounting to Pta 250 million. This intervention falls out of the scope of application of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty because it was put into effect before the entry of Spain into the Community.
A loan at other than market conditions