, Decision_act (EU) 1991/1

In forcesince 20 Dec 1989

Pta 1 830 milion; a loan at other than market conditions of Pta 2 085 million; subsidies totalling Pta 1 095 million; interest subsidies being worth Pta 9 million; and extraordinary subsidies to the workers made redundant valued at Pta 1 500 million. They are discussed in detail in the fourth recital.

After a first analysis, the Commission considered that the aid in question was caught by the prohibition provided for in Article 92 (1) of the Treaty, and did not prima facie satisfy the conditions for exemption under paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article. Therefore, the Commission decided to initiate the Article 93 (2) procedure in respect of the aid.

The decision was communicated to the Spanish Government by letter dated 28 November 1988, giving it notice to submit its comments. The other Member States were informed by letters dated 6 February 1989. Notice to other third interested parties was given on 15 February 1989 by means of the publication in the Official Journal of the European Communities.

III

The Spanish Government answered the Commission's letter by telex dated 15 February 1989.

Concerning the loan at other than market conditions, the Spanish Government stated that it originated in an arrangement made by Fogasa - the national fund for the safeguarding of employees' rights in the event of insolvency of their employers - and Magefesa.

Fogasa had paid, in place of Magefesa within the ceilings established in its regulation, salaries and indemnities pending of payment to the workers made redundant. The loan in question was decided by the fund with Magefesa to recover the said advances. Therefore, the Spanish Government concluded that this loan should not be viewed as an aid to Magefesa but rather an aid to the workers, these latter being the direct beneficiaries of the measure.

As regards the subsidies, the Spanish Government claimed that, like in the previous case, they were aids to the workers and not to Magefesa. The governments of the autonomous Communities had paid that money to Magefesa to enable it to pay off the remaining part of salaries and indemnities due and not advanced by the national fund, because they exceeded the ceilings established under its regulation. In consequence, this State intervention should be seen as a measure for complementary social protection of redundant workers.