As to the assistance granted by one of the autonomous governments concerned, in particular that of the Basque Country in the form of loan guarantees and subsidies, the Spanish Governments claimed that they were awarded under an aid regime existing in Spain before its entry into the Community and notified at the time of the accession without the Commission making any observation. The Spanish Government also argued that the aid regime in question was of a regional nature, for which, according to the Spanish opinion, the Commission foresees the compatibility of operating aids.
Lastly, concerning the extraordinary subsidies granted in favour of workers accepting dismissal, the Spanish Government stated that, contrary to the Commission's first appraisal, this measure had not had any effect on the negotiations between Magefesa and its workers for the completion of the manning level adjustment. This State intervention should be viewed as a general measure under the social policy of the Spanish Government intended to mitigate the adverse consequences of unemployment for those workers no longer being entitled to unemployment pay.
Following receipt of the comments from the Spanish Government, by letter of 27 February 1989 the Commission drew the attention of the Spanish authorities to the fact that no answer was given to an essential point for reservation raised in the letter communicating the initiation of the Article 93 (2) procedure; the absence of notification of a sound restructuring plan for the companies of Magefesa that, duly endorsed by the public authorities, could serve as a reference for the discussion about the compatibility of the aid.
The Spanish authorities replied by telex dated 31 March 1989, communicating that to that date the administrative authorities concerned had not approved any industrial restructuring plan for the companies of Magefesa.
Within the framework of the consultation of other interested parties, the governments of three other Member States, and two industrial federations, submitted observations, all supporting the Commission's position and underlying the danger of distortion of competition arising from the aid.