This Annex lays down methods for determining data required for reporting the data listed in Annex IV at installation level, as well as rules for attribution of these data to sub-installations, with the exception of data monitored in accordance with a monitoring plan approved by the competent authority pursuant to Regulation (EU) No 601/2012. Data determined in accordance with Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 shall be used under this Regulation where relevant.
‘Data set’ for the purposes of this Annex means one type of data, either at installation level or sub-installation level as relevant in the circumstances, as any of the following:
the amount of fuels or materials consumed or produced by a process as relevant for the calculation-based monitoring methodology, expressed in terajoules, mass in tonnes, or for gases as volume in normal cubic metres, as appropriate, including for waste gases;
a calculation factor as used by Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 (i.e. composition of a material or fuel or waste gas);
net quantity of measurable heat, and the relevant parameters required for determining this quantity, in particular:
mass flow of heat transfer medium, and
enthalpy of transmitted and returned heat transfer medium, as specified by composition, temperature, pressure and saturation;
quantities of non-measurable heat, specified by the relevant quantities of fuels used for producing the heat, and the net calorific value (NCV) of the fuel mix;
quantities of electricity;
quantities of CO2 transferred between installations.
‘Determination methodology’ means either of the following:
a methodology of identifying, collecting and processing data already available at the installation for data sets of historical data or;
a monitoring methodology for a specific data set based on an approved monitoring methodology plan.
In addition, the definitions of ‘source stream’, ‘emission source’, ‘inherent risk’, ‘control risk’ and ‘emission factor’ as set in Article 3 of Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 shall apply.
The operator shall determine data for the purpose of compiling a baseline data report in accordance with point (a) of Article 4(2) using methods contained in this Annex. Where this Annex does not describe applicable methods for determining a specific data set, the operator shall apply a suitable method, subject to the approval by the competent authority of the monitoring methodology plan in accordance with Article 6. A method shall be deemed suitable where the operator ensures that any metering, analyses, sampling, calibrations and validations for the determination of the specific data set are carried out by applying methods based on corresponding EN standards. Where such standards are not available, the methods shall be based on suitable ISO standards or national standards. Where no applicable published standards exist, suitable draft standards, industry best practice guidelines or other scientifically proven methodologies shall be used, limiting sampling and measurement bias.
Where data for a specific data set are not available for each sub-installation, the operator shall propose an appropriate method for determining the required data for each individual sub-installation, except for cases referred to in the second and third subparagraphs of Article 10(3). For this purpose, either of the following principles shall be applied depending on which principle yields more accurate results:
where different products are produced one after the other in the same production line, inputs, outputs and corresponding emissions shall be attributed sequentially based on the usage time per year for each sub-installation;
inputs, outputs and corresponding emissions shall be attributed based on the mass or volume of individual products produced or estimates based on the ratio of free reaction enthalpies of the chemical reactions involved or based on another suitable distribution key that is corroborated by a sound scientific methodology.
Where several measurement instruments of different quality are contributing to measurement results, either of the following methods shall be used for splitting installation-level data on quantities of materials, fuels, measurable heat or electricity to sub-installations:
Determination of the split based on a determination method, such as sub-metering, estimate, correlation, used equally for each sub-installation. Where the sum of the sub-installation data is different from the data determined separately for the installation, a uniform ‘reconciliation factor’ shall be applied for uniform correction to meet the total figure of the installation as follows:
RecF = DInst/Σ DSI | (Equation 1)
where RecF is the reconciliation factor, DInst is the data value determined for the installation as a whole, and DSI are the data values for the different sub-installations. The data for each sub-installation are then corrected as follows:
DSI,corr = DSI × RecF | (Equation 2)
If only one sub-installation's data are unknown or of lower quality than the data of other sub-installations, known sub-installation data may be subtracted from the total installation data. This method is preferred only for sub-installations which contribute smaller quantities to the installation's allocation.
The operator may make use of measurement systems or analytical procedures outside the operator's own control:
where the operator does not have their own measurement instrument or analytical procedure available for the determination of a specific data set;
where determination of a data set by the operator's own measurement instruments or analytical procedures is technically not feasible or would incur unreasonable costs;
where the operator demonstrates to the satisfaction of the competent authority that the measurement system or analytical procedure outside the operator's control gives more reliable results and is less prone to control risks.
To that end, the operator may revert to one of the following data sources:
amounts from invoices issued by a trade partner, provided that a commercial transaction between two independent trade partners takes place;
direct readings from the measurement systems;
use of empirical correlations provided by a competent and independent body, such as equipment suppliers, engineering providers or accredited laboratories.
Where no direct metering or analysis approach is available for a required data set, in particular for cases where net measurable heat is going into different production processes, the operator shall propose the use of an indirect determination method, such as:
calculation based on a known chemical or physical process, using appropriate accepted literature values for the chemical and physical properties of substances involved, appropriate stoichiometric factors and thermodynamic properties such as reaction enthalpies, as appropriate;
calculation based on the installation's design data such as the energy efficiencies of technical units or calculated energy consumption per unit of product;
correlations based on empirical tests for determining estimation values for the required data set from non-calibrated equipment or data documented in production protocols. For this purpose the operator shall ensure that the correlation satisfies the requirements of good engineering practice and that it is applied only to determine values which fall into the range for which it was established. The operator shall evaluate the validity of such correlations at least once a year.
Where an operator claims that applying a specific determination methodology is technically not feasible, the competent authority shall assess the technical feasibility taking the operator's justification into account. That justification shall be based on the operator having technical resources capable of meeting the needs of a proposed system or requirement that can be implemented in the required time for the purposes of this Regulation. Those technical resources shall include availability of required techniques and technology.
Where an operator claims that applying a specific determination methodology incurs unreasonable costs, the competent authority shall assess the unreasonable nature of the costs, taking into account the operator's justification.
The competent authority shall consider costs unreasonable where the operator’s cost estimation exceeds the benefit of a specific determination methodology. To that end, the benefit shall be calculated by multiplying an improvement factor with a reference price referred to in Article 18, paragraph 1 of Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 [Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 of 19 December 2018 on the monitoring and reporting of greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council and amending Commission Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 (OJ L 334, 31.12.2018, p. 1).] and costs shall include an appropriate depreciation period based on the economic lifetime of the equipment, where applicable.
The improvement factor shall be 1 % of the most recently determined sub-installation's annual allocation free of charge. By way of derogation from this calculation method, the competent authority may allow operators to determine the improvement factor as 1 % of the affected CO2 equivalent. The affected CO2 equivalent shall be one the following, depending on the parameter for which the improvement of methodology is considered:
In the case of a fuel or material containing carbon, including waste gases, the emissions that would result if the carbon contained in the annual quantity of the fuel or material were converted into CO2;
In the case of emissions monitored by a measurement-based methodology, the annual emissions of the respective emission source;
In the case of measurable heat, the respective annual amount of measurable heat multiplied by the heat benchmark;
In the case of non-measurable heat, the respective annual amount of non-measurable heat multiplied by the fuel benchmark;
In the case of electricity, the respective annual amount of electricity multiplied by the factor specified in Article 22(3);
In the case of the quantity of a product for which a product benchmark applies, the sub-installation's preliminary annual number of emission allowances allocated free of charge determined in accordance with Article 16(2) for the first year of the respective allocation period. Where the relevant benchmark has not yet been determined in accordance with Article 10a(2) of Directive 2003/87/EC, the respective benchmark specified in Annex I to this Regulation shall be used.
Measures relating to the improvement of an installation's monitoring methodology shall not be deemed to incur unreasonable costs up to an accumulated amount of EUR 2000 per year. For installations with low emissions in accordance with Article 47 of Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 that threshold shall be EUR 500 per year.
To determine the most accurate available data sources, the operator shall select the most accurate data sources which are technically feasible and do not incur unreasonable costs, and which ensure a clear data flow with lowest inherent risk and control risk (referred to hereinafter as ‘primary data sources’). The operator shall use the primary data sources for the purpose of compiling the baseline data report.
To the extent feasible without incurring unreasonable costs, for the purpose of the control system in accordance with Article 11, the operator shall strive to identify and use additional data sources or methods for determining data which allow corroboration of the primary data sources (referred to hereinafter as ‘corroborating data sources’). The selected corroborating data sources, if any, shall be documented in the written procedures referred to in Article 11(2) and in the monitoring methodology plan.
For selecting the primary data sources, the operator shall compare all available data sources for the same data set using the generic data sources listed in sections 4.4 to 4.6, and use one of the highest ranked data sources that are considered as most accurate data sources. Only if any of the derogations in accordance with Article 7(2) apply, other data sources may be used. In such case, the next highest ranked data source shall be applied unless it is technically not feasible, would incur unreasonable costs or another data source has equivalent or lower level of associated uncertainty. Where needed, further data sources can be considered.
For selecting the corroborating data sources, the operator shall compare all available data sources for the same data set using the generic data sources listed in sections 4.4 to 4.6, and use an available data source other than the most accurate available data source.
For selecting data sources in order to determine all the data required in accordance with Annex IV, the operator shall proceed for the following main types of data sets as follows:
For the determination of quantities of products, fuels and other materials the operator shall take into account the generic data sources and their hierarchy laid down in section 4.4 of this Annex;
For the determination of quantities of energy flows (measurable or non-measurable heat, electricity) the operator shall take into account the generic data sources and their hierarchy laid down in section 4.5 of this Annex;
For the determination of properties of products, fuels and other materials, the operator shall take into account the generic data sources and their hierarchy laid down in section 4.6 of this Annex.
For the purpose of improving the monitoring methodology plan, the operator shall check regularly and at least once per year, whether new data sources have become available. In case such new data sources are considered more accurate in accordance with the ranking described in sections 4.4 to 4.6, they shall be applied and the monitoring methodology plan shall be changed in accordance with Article 9.
The following generic data sources shall be used selecting most accurate available data sources for quantifying amounts (expressed as tonnes or Nm3) of materials, fuels, waste gases or products entering or leaving the installation, or any sub-installation:
Methods in accordance with the monitoring plan approved under Regulation (EU) No 601/2012;
Readings of measuring instruments subject to national legal metrological control or measuring instruments compliant with the requirements of Directive 2014/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council [Directive 2014/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on the harmonisation of the laws of the Member States relating to the making available on the market of non-automatic weighing instruments (OJ L 96, 29.3.2014, p. 107).] or Directive 2014/32/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council [Directive 2014/32/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on the harmonisation of the laws of the Member States relating to the making available on the market of measuring instruments (OJ L 96, 29.3.2014, p. 149).] for direct determination of a data set;
Readings of measuring instruments under the operator's control for direct determination of a data set not falling under point (b);
Readings of measuring instruments not under the operator's control for direct determination of a data set not falling under point (b);
Readings of measuring instruments for indirect determination of a data set, provided that an appropriate correlation between the measurement and the data set in question is established in line with section 3.4;
Other methods, in particular for historical data or where no other data source can be identified by the operator as available.
For selecting data sources for the purpose of Article 7(1), only the data sources listed in points (a) and (b) of the first paragraph are considered representing most accurate data sources while the data source referred to in point (a) of that paragraph shall be used to the extent that it covers the respective data set. The data sources referred to in points (c) to (f) of the first paragraph are considered less accurate in the descending hierarchical order from point (c) to point (f).
The following generic data sources shall be used for selecting most accurate available data sources quantifying amounts, expressed as TJ or GWh, of measurable heat or electricity entering or leaving the installation, or any sub-installation:
Readings of measuring instruments subject to national legal metrological control or measuring instruments compliant with the requirements of the Directive 2014/31/EU or Directive 2014/32/EU for direct determination of a data set;
Readings of measuring instruments under the operator's control for direct determination of a data set not falling under point a;
Readings of measuring instruments not under the operator's control for direct determination of a data set not falling under point a;
Readings of measuring instruments for indirect determination of a data set, provided that an appropriate correlation between the measurement and the data set in question is established in line with section 3.4 of this Annex;
Calculation of a proxy for the determining net amounts of measurable heat in accordance with method 3 of section 7.2;
Other methods, in particular for historical data or where no other data source can be identified by the operator as available.
For selecting data sources for the purpose of Article 7(1), only the data source referred to in point (a) of the first paragraph is considered representing most accurate data sources. The data sources referred to in points (b) to (f) of the first paragraph are considered less accurate in the descending hierarchical order from point (b) to point (f).
For situations where no information is available for some parameters (such as temperature and amount of condensate returned) required to determine net flows of measurable heat, the provisions of section 7 are to be applied. In accordance with section 7, several parameters need to be determined in order to result in annual net amounts of measurable heat. Therefore the overall result for the annual net amount of heat should be considered the purpose of the simplified uncertainly assessment in accordance with point (c) of Article 7(2) for the for selection of the methods referred to in points (b) to (f) of the first paragraph when deviating from the selection of data sources representing most accurate data sources.
The following generic data sources shall be used selecting most accurate available data sources for determining properties such as moisture or purity of the substance, carbon content, net calorific value, biomass content, etc. of products, materials, fuels or waste gases as inputs or outputs of the installation or sub-installation:
Methods for determining calculation factors in accordance with the monitoring plan approved under Regulation (EU) No 601/2012;
Laboratory analyses in accordance with section 6.1 of this Annex;
Simplified laboratory analyses in accordance with section 6.2 of this Annex;
Constant values based on one of the following data sources:
standard factors used by the Member State for its national inventory submission to the Secretariat of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change;
literature values agreed with the competent authority, including standard factors published by the competent authority, which are compatible with factors referred to under the previous sub-item, but they are representative of more disaggregated sources of fuel streams;
values specified and guaranteed by the supplier of a fuel or material where the operator can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the competent authority that the carbon content exhibits a 95 % confidence interval of not more than 1 %;
Constant values based on one of the following data sources:
standard factors and stoichiometric factors listed in Annex VI to Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 or listed in the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) guidelines;
values based on analyses carried out in the past, where the operator can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the competent authority that those values are representative for future batches of the same fuel or material;
Other values based on scientific evidence.
For selecting data sources for the purpose of Article 7(1), only the data sources referred to in points (a) and (b) of the first paragraph are considered representing most accurate data sources while data source referred to in point (a) of that paragraph shall be used to the extent that it covers the respective data set. The data sources referred to in points (c) to (e) of the first paragraph are considered less accurate in the descending hierarchical order from point (c) to point (e).
Where the operator has to determine annual quantities of fuels or materials, including products relating to product benchmark sub-installations, the operator shall determine such quantities at installation level or for each relevant sub-installation, as required, in one of the following ways:
based on continual metering at the process where the material is consumed or produced;
based on aggregation of metering of quantities separately delivered or produced taking into account relevant stock changes.
For the purposes of point (b) of the first paragraph, the quantity of fuel or material consumed during the calendar year at the installation or sub-installation shall be calculated as the quantity of fuel or material imported during the calendar year, minus the quantity of fuel or material exported, plus the quantity of fuel or material in stock at the beginning of the calendar year, minus the quantity of fuel or material in stock at the end of the calendar year.
For the purposes of point (b) of the first paragraph, the quantity of product or other material exported during the calendar year shall be calculated as the quantity of product or material exported during the reporting period, minus the quantity imported or recycled into the process, minus the quantity of product or material in stock at the beginning of the calendar year, plus the quantity of product or material in stock at the end of the calendar year.
Where it is technically not feasible or would incur unreasonable costs to determine quantities in stock by direct measurement, the operator may estimate those quantities based on one of the following:
data from previous years and correlated with appropriate activity levels for the reporting period;
documented procedures and respective data in audited financial statements for the reporting period.