71 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.3. Compatibility of the aid: derogation under Article 87(3) of the EC Treaty › 5.3.4. Avoidance of undue distortions of competition, Decision_act (EU) 2007/257

In forcesince 20 Dec 2006

Furthermore, the Polish authorities maintain that the recipient has sold a number of profitable production companies, thereby limiting its activities and production capacity. At least two big subsidiaries (HSW-Walcownia Blach Sp. z o.o. and HSW-Huta Stali Jakosciowych) were profitable and were sold at a profit. The combined turnover of these two subsidiaries in 2005 was PLN 460 million (EUR 121 million) with a workforce of 1000, whereas the core activity of HSW group (HSW and HSW-Trading) achieved a turnover of PLN 430 million (EUR 113,1 million) with 2400 employees. The two subsidiaries that were sold produced finished steel products. At the time of the sale, according to an evaluation submitted to the Commission, these two subsidiaries were profitable, with the prospect of a return on sales of about 6 %. The two subsidiaries formed a very significant part of the HSW group, with profitable activities and good market prospects.