57 V. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › Compatibility of the aid to winegrowers and winegrowing enterprises › Re b) Counterpart, Decision_act (EU) 2007/57

In forcesince 7 Jun 2006

Under point 9.4 of the Agricultural guidelines, beneficiaries must make an adequate contribution in return — normally consisting of a definitive and irrevocable decision to scrap or irreversibly close down the production capacity concerned. Beneficiaries must give a legally-binding undertaking that the closure is definitive and irrevocable. The German authorities stated that no legally-binding undertakings were given by the winegrowers regarding the closure of their own capacity. As regards wine production, the obligation to deliver grapes, must and wine is tantamount to shutting down such capacity, but only for the five-year period covered by that obligation. The Commission concludes that this condition has not been met.