Where an operator travels to another Member State to exercise a service activity there, a distinction should be made between situations covered by the freedom of establishment and those covered, due to the temporary nature of the activities concerned, by the free movement of services. As regards the distinction between the freedom of establishment and the free movement of services, according to the case law of the Court of Justice the key element is whether or not the operator is established in the Member State where it provides the service concerned. If the operator is established in the Member State where it provides its services, it should come under the scope of application of the freedom of establishment. If, by contrast, the operator is not established in the Member State where the service is provided, its activities should be covered by the free movement of services. The Court of Justice has consistently held that the temporary nature of the activities in question should be determined in the light not only of the duration of the provision of the service, but also of its regularity, periodical nature or continuity. The fact that the activity is temporary should not mean that the provider may not equip itself with some forms of infrastructure in the Member State where the service is provided, such as an office, chambers or consulting rooms, in so far as such infrastructure is necessary for the purposes of providing the service in question.
Recital 77, Directive (EU) 2006/123
Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar delivered on 16 July 2015. R.L. Trijber v College van Burgemeester en Wethouders van Amsterdam and J. HaDecision
In referring to Chapter III of Directive 2006/123, the referring court sees the current cases as being governed by the rules on establishment rather than by those on services. This appears also to me to be the correct starting point: it …
16 Jul 2015 · 62014CC0340
Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 17 September 2015. European Commission v Hungary.Decision
I observe that Directive 2006/123 codified that case-law, [See recital 77 of the directive.] so that those principles apply also where the directive is applied.
17 Sep 2015 · 62014CC0179
Opinion of Advocate General Cruz Villalón delivered on 16 November 2011. Duomo Gpa Srl and Others v Comune di Baranzate and Comune di VenegoDecision
The use of some form of physical base in the State where the activity is pursued is not absolutely decisive either. It was held in Gebhard that it is open to ‘the provider of services within the meaning of the Treaty [to] equip himself …
16 Nov 2011 · 62010CC0357
Opinion of Advocate General Emiliou delivered on 15 September 2022. Administración General del Estado and Others v Asociación para la DefensDecision
As I indicated in point 2 above, the Services Directive establishes general provisions facilitating the exercise of the fundamental freedoms which are protected by Articles 49 and 56 TFEU. Those two freedoms relate to different aspects of …
15 Sep 2022 · 62021CC0292
Opinion of Advocate General Campos Sánchez-Bordona delivered on 4 July 2024. Halmer Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft UG v Rechtsanwaltskammer MünchDecision
Recital 77 is worded as follows: ‘Where an operator travels to another Member State to exercise a service activity there, a distinction should be made between situations covered by the freedom of establishment and those covered, due to …
4 Jul 2024 · 62023CC0295