According to the case-law of the Court of Justice, the assessment of whether certain activities, in particular activities which are publicly funded or provided by public entities, constitute a ‘service’ has to be carried out on a case by case basis in the light of all their characteristics, in particular the way they are provided, organised and financed in the Member State concerned. The Court of Justice has held that the essential characteristic of remuneration lies in the fact that it constitutes consideration for the services in question and has recognised that the characteristic of remuneration is absent in the case of activities performed, for no consideration, by the State or on behalf of the State in the context of its duties in the social, cultural, educational and judicial fields, such as courses provided under the national education system, or the management of social security schemes which do not engage in economic activity. The payment of a fee by recipients, for example, a tuition or enrolment fee paid by students in order to make a certain contribution to the operating expenses of a system, does not in itself constitute remuneration because the service is still essentially financed by public funds. These activities are, therefore, not covered by the definition of service in Article 50 of the Treaty and do not therefore fall within the scope of this Directive.
Recital 34, Directive (EU) 2006/123
Opinion of Advocate General Emiliou delivered on 15 September 2022. Administración General del Estado and Others v Asociación para la DefensDecision
From the outset, it is clear to me that an activity such as that at issue in the main proceedings, which is a ‘service’ within the meaning of Article 4(1) of the Services Directive, [The term ‘service’ is defined by that provision …
15 Sep 2022 · 62021CC0292
Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 15 November 2018. Openbaar Ministerie v Freddy Lucien Magdalena Kirschstein and Thierry FransDecision
Recital 34 of the Services Directive reads as follows: ‘According to the case-law of the Court of Justice, the assessment of whether certain activities, in particular activities which are publicly funded or provided by public entities, …
15 Nov 2018 · 62017CC0393