In its reply to the statement of objections, Degussa submits that the Commission's own evidence supports its claim that Degussa and Rhône-Poulenc acted completely autonomously on the market between 1989 and 1990 (see recitals 101 and 102). This argument cannot, however, be followed. Not only does the Commission have ample evidence showing that Rhône-Poulenc and Degussa actually continued to take part in the infringement between 1989 and 1991 (see recitals 95 to 125), but the fact that Rhône-Poulenc and Degussa may well have had "hidden agendas" causing them to disregard to some extent the commitments made towards the other cartel participants does not imply that they did not implement the cartel agreement. As the Court of First Instance held in the Cascades case, "an undertaking which, despite colluding with its competitors follows a more or less independent policy on the market may simply be trying to exploit the cartel for its own benefit"(105).
The size of the relevant geographic market