None of the arguments used by the parties to minimise the Commission's finding that the cartel had an actual effect on the market is conclusive. The explanations for the failure to achieve the target prices (in particular as from 1992 to 1993), may have some validity, but they do not demonstrate in a convincing manner that the implementation of the cartel agreement could not have played a role in the setting and fluctuation of prices on the methionine market. Indeed, given that the parties had replaced the uncertain situation of free competition with continuous collusion, prices were necessarily established at a level different to that which would have prevailed in a competitive market.
Recital 287, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674
In forcesince 2 Jul 2002