Recital 282, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674

In forcesince 2 Jul 2002

Nippon Soda submits that its ability to cause significant damage to other operators or consumers in any market within the Commission's jurisdiction is virtually nil because it has no sales of its own in the EEA and played only a passive role in the cartel. Nippon Soda sells its methionine to Mitsui in Japan, which then sells the product in the EEA, where it has an estimated market share of only [ ]*. In addition, Nippon Soda submits that the cartel itself was singularly ineffective (see recitals 274 and 275). According to Nippon Soda, the evidence in the Commission's file demonstrates that the participants had only a limited ability to influence the market. Indeed, Nippon Soda submits that in practice, the producers had neither the ability nor the will actually to fix the market price, regardless of the discussions at their meetings. In support of its arguments, Nippon Soda cites the Commission's own evidence for the 1992 to 1993 period, which shows that prices routinely fell below the target price of 6,20 DEM/kg.