With regard to the claim that non-deductible expenditure is not included in the base to which the mark-up rate is applied under the cost-plus pricing method, the Commission is able to accept some of the arguments put forward by Luxembourg. The logic behind this clearly stems from a comparison with the traditional method of taxation. Tax does not form part of genuine business expenditure but is a payment based on its trading result. The exclusion of donations seems to follow the same logic in that they do not represent genuine business costs. In other words, such non-deductible expenditure is not likely to contribute to the realisation of a taxable result. Since the existence of an advantage has been established as a result of the systematic application of a 5 % rate, it is not necessary to determine whether the same considerations apply to bonuses and attendance fees since they represent distributions of net profits.
Competition and trade between Member States are affected