Recital 34, Decision_act (EU) 2003/501

In forcesince 16 Oct 2002

According to Luxembourg, the specificity criterion is not met because Circular 119 stems from the normal application of the Luxembourg tax rules. The Circular applies to all international groups of a sufficient size and forms part of efforts to combat abnormally low transfer prices. The only conditions imposed relate to the size of the group and to its establishments in several countries. Such limitations are necessary in order to guarantee that serious operations are managed from Luxembourg in a volume which is sufficient to give rise to difficulties in determining the transfer prices of the enterprises concerned. The principles to be applied in determining the taxable result of a coordination centre, as proposed in the Circular, are based on the rules for transfer prices set out by the OECD, which are general in scope and applicable to all taxpayers encountering intra-group invoicing. The Circular does not involve the application of a lower tax rate to coordination centres but, at most, lays down how the tax base is to be calculated, taking account of the specific characteristics of multinational companies. It is therefore a tax measure of a purely technical nature, which, according to the Commission, does not constitute State aid.