It is irrelevant that Circular 119 required the parent company to be subject abroad to a tax corresponding to Luxembourg corporation tax or that the foreign country in which the parent company originated could apply measures to prevent tax avoidance because these aspects do not demonstrate that the Luxembourg scheme for coordination centres did not confer any advantage or that any advantage which might have been conferred would have been justified. The conduct of other Member States, and in particular the possibility that they might take account of the advantage conferred by a Member States in an attempt to reduce or cancel its effects, does not in any way detract from the reality of that advantage. In any case, the method applied by Luxembourg in taxing cross-border intra-group services, which is based on cost-plus pricing, might not tally with the method used in other Member States whereby the taxable profit is calculated on the basis of the difference between the enterprise's income and charges. If this is the case, there is a risk that overcharging might give rise to a reduction in the tax burden in another Member State which would not be offset by an increase in the tax burden in Luxembourg. In this case, the advantage obtained in Luxembourg would come on top of the advantage obtained in another Member State and would not be in any way offset.
Recital 48, Decision_act (EU) 2003/501
In forcesince 16 Oct 2002