Recital 83, Decision_act (EU) 2003/1

In forcesince 18 Dec 2002

To begin with, as the French authorities themselves recognise(70), the products involved in the Toulouse explosion were straight ammonium nitrate fertilisers of high nitrogen content which did not meet the requirements of Directive 80/876/EEC or technical-grade ammonium nitrates, whose explosive properties are well known, and not NK fertilisers which complied with the requirements of Directive 76/116/EEC. It is therefore not possible to draw any causal link between the latter EC fertilisers and this accident. Lastly, the French authorities state that, up to know, no theories as to the causes of this explosion have yet been definitively ruled out, as the causes of the explosion are still unknown(71). Lastly, the French authorities admit that the theory relating to the possible role of products containing chlorine in triggering the Toulouse explosion is based on waste containing chlorine being mistakenly placed in a warehouse used to store ammonium nitrate, and not on the presence of chlorine in the form of potassium chloride in the make-up of the fertilisers(72). The Commission considers that the allegations being made are too general and lack substance. They cannot even be considered scientific. As a result, it is the Commission's opinion that, in this case, there is no justification for applying the precautionary principle.

  • celex=31976L0116
  • celex=31980L0876