Recital 82, Decision_act (EU) 2003/1

In forcesince 18 Dec 2002

As for the arguments drawn from the Toulouse catastrophe(67), which, in the view of the French authorities, justifies recourse to the precautionary principle, the Commission must point out that "recourse to the precautionary principle presupposes that potentially dangerous effects deriving from a phenomenon, product or process have been identified, and that scientific evaluation does not allow the risk to be determined with sufficient certainty"(68). The precautionary principle places an obligation on Member States to provide new data which raises serious doubts with regard to health or the environment, and which, in accordance with the common rules on the burden of proof, is serious and conclusive evidence and, without setting aside scientific uncertainty, makes it possible to justify taking precautionary measures. Moreover, it follows from the Community courts' interpretation of the precautionary principle(69) that a preventive measure may be taken only if the risk, although the reality and extent thereof have not been "fully" demonstrated by conclusive scientific evidence, appears nevertheless to be adequately backed up by the scientific data available at the time when the measure was taken. The grounds for a preventive measure cannot validly be a purely hypothetical approach to risk, based on mere hypotheses which have not yet been scientifically confirmed. The precautionary principle can therefore apply only in situations in which there is a risk, notably to human health and the environment, which, although it is not founded on mere hypotheses that have not been scientifically confirmed, has not yet been fully demonstrated.