Recital 80, Decision_act (EU) 2002/191

In forcesince 3 Apr 2001

Secondly, although it can be accepted that the past bidding activities of the Parties were to some degree complementary, the notified concentration will enhance the new entity's possibilities of participating in public tenders. Indeed, it should be noted that the Parties only competed against each other in approximately half of the projects tendered out in Germany between 1995 and 1999. Both Bombardier and ADtranz submitted separate bids(32) for a total of [0 < 10]* contracts examined by the Commission, representing a value of EUR [... %]* million ([50-60 %]* of the overall market) and a volume of [... %]* cars [40-50 %], whilst in [0 < 10]* cases examined by the Commission, representing a value of EUR [... %]* million [30-40 %]* and a volume of [... %]* cars [30-40 %]*, only one of the Parties participated as a bidder. In another two cases examined by the Commission, representing a value of EUR [... %]* million [10-20 %]* and a volume of [... %]* cars [10-20 %]*, Bombardier and ADtranz were part of the same consortium and thus did not compete against each other. Nevertheless, the takeover of ADtranz will necessarily result in a strengthening of Bombardier's competitive position in that market. In fact, the enlargement of the new entity's product portfolio, covering the whole range of products in the tram and LRV sector, will allow it to submit bids in any public tender to be published in Germany(33).