, Special Report No 3/99 on the management and control of interest Prate subsidies by the…

In forcesince 16 Jun 1999

3.14. In connection with the TF SMEs, the problem is different, as the subsidies were paid globally in advance (ECU 93,5 million between 1994 and 1996), basically for reasons of budgetary availability, and were paid over to the beneficiaries by the EIB (ECU 93,4 million) between 1995 and 1998. The time lag involved is not discernible in the EU's financial statements. At 31 December 1997 subsidies that had still not been paid over to beneficiaries amounted to ECU 0,1 million. In addition, the interest earnings generated by the funds held on current account at the EIB (some ECU 9 million) have not been established as budgetary revenue.

3.15. With regard to NCI earthquake loans, and Madeira, the subsidies are paid over on each interest maturity date. Under the cashPaccounting system, accrued interestPrate subsidies not yet due are not entered in the accounts. Furthermore, the unaccrued amounts that are to be paid at a later date, which amounted to ECU 6,1 million for NCI earthquake loans and ECU 3,3 million for Madeira on 31 December 1997, are not shown outside the balance sheet.

3.16. The three preceding paragraphs show that the same economic situation is presented in the accounts in different ways, depending on the technical setPup of the operations. It is therefore difficult to gain an understanding of the situation by examining the financial statements.

CONCLUSION

4.1. As regards the sound financial management of the subsidies, the Commission should:

–

ensure that where intermediaries are used, they do not receive unreasonable levels of remuneration and that certain financial institutions have not been favoured over other competitors, but have been selected in a satisfactorily transparent and equitable manner,

–

evaluate their efficiency by measuring the rate of achievement of the set objectives, wherever possible (see paragraph 3.9), and by determining the real impact of the subsidies (see paragraphs 3.10 to 3.11).

4.2. Harmonisation of the entry of the interestPrate subsidies into the accounts contained in the EU's and the EDF's financial statements could be improved to provide a clearer picture, and be accompanied by more comprehensive information (see paragraphs 3.13 to 3.16). The Commission should also check the calculations and verify the appropriateness of the discount rates applied (see paragraph 3.12).