, Special Report No 3/99 on the management and control of interest Prate subsidies by the…

In forcesince 16 Jun 1999

3.11. With regard to the two measures conceived specifically to create jobs (TF SMEs and Article 56 of the ECSC Treaty), the number of jobs created is used as a criterion for judging their efficiency. However, the Commission presents the results in statistical terms, without analysing the causal connection between the jobs created and the subsidies paid out. The Court carried out audits of both measures on the premises of the beneficiaries, from which it has concluded that the subsidies had almost no real impact and were more like a windfall for the beneficiaries who, by virtue of investing in job creation, had received this Community aid, even though their investments had been made for reasons unconnected with the measures.

Entry of the subsidies in the accounts

3.12. For most measures the Commission enters the subsidies it pays to the EIB in the accounts without checking the related calculations, even when the subsidies concerned were paid in advance and calculated in present value terms. The Court examined the files at the Commission and found no sign of any checks having been carried out before sums were recorded.

3.13. In the case of the general budget and the EDFs (the situation is different as regards the ECSC operating budget), expenditure on interestPrate subsidies is entered in the accounts at the time the respective commitments are entered into and then when the respective payments are made. When the amounts paid to the EIB correspond to the total sum of the present value of the subsidies in respect of a loan lasting several years (see paragraph 2.15), the Bank enters the portion relating to subsequent financial years under its liabilities for as long as it holds this portion (subsidies received in advance amounted to ECU 361,6 million on 31 December 1997), as it could be required to pay part of it back to the EC or the EDF, for example, in the event of early repayment of the corresponding loans. On the other hand, neither the EC nor the EDF have any sort of indicator (for example, to denote claims or forecast claims) which would require them to focus their attention on what becomes of these subsidies once paid, as the corresponding amounts are not entered on the assets side of the EC(26) or EDF balance sheets.