conformity with the principles of compliance with the aims of the Directive, absence of distortions of competition, and the extent of the measure referred to in Article 9(2) of the Directive.
Thus an exemption may not be granted with the objective of allowing the airport a further general adaptation period in addition to that already granted by Article 1 of the Directive. It must permit the airport to overcome the specific constraints which it may encounter when the market is opened up. Any exemption must therefore be examined in the light of the specific constraints put forward in justification of the impossibility of opening up the market within the time allowed. In addition, in accordance with the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Communities, any exception must be interpreted strictly and when the scope of an exemption is determined this must take account of the purpose of the measure in question.
It is in the light of these considerations that this exemption has to be examined.
In accordance with Article 9(4) of the Directive, the Commission has made a detailed analysis of the alleged space and capacity constraints, whether the decision taken is appropriate to those constraints, and the measures put forward to overcome them. Its examination drew upon the studies provided by the German authorities, and upon the visit that it made to Stuttgart airport on 24 August 1998 and, finally, benefited from the technical assessment made at its request by Symonds Travers Morgan.
Examination of the constraints referred to by the German authorities
2.1. Available space
Stuttgart airport currently has 39 aircraft parking positions, 18 of which require the use of pusher tugs (TIPO positions). The Commission experts observed that it was quite feasible to park equipment at the head of aircraft in these positions. The airport's argument that radio guidance of aircraft to their positions prevents parking of equipment for safety reasons is unacceptable since this is common in many international airports and poses no particular problem. This problem can be solved by clear marking of parking places and supervision to ensure proper safety of the aircraft position when the aircraft arrives - normal safety procedures at many airports with nose-in parking.