, Decision_act (EU) 1998/630

In force

However, where specific space or capacity constraints, arising in particular from the rate of utilisation or of space occupation make it impossible to authorise self-handling to the extent provided for by the Directive, the Member State concerned may, on the basis of Article 9(1)(d), abolish that right or restrict it to a single user.

However, under Article 9(2) any such exemption must:

–

specify the category or categories of ground handling services for which the exemption is granted and the specific constraints of available space or capacity which justify it,

–

be accompanied by a plan of appropriate measures to overcome the constraints.

Moreover, pursuant to Article 9(2), it must not:

–

unduly prejudice the aims of the Directive,

–

give rise to distortions of competition,

–

extend further than necessary.

Thus, as again pointed out by the Commission in its Decisions of 14 January 1998 on Frankfurt and Dusseldorf airports (6), the main aim of the Directive is to liberalise the groundhandling services market. The restrictions imposed on third parties consist of restrictions of freedom of such parties to provide such services. By analogy with the State measures restricting the freedom to provide services (7), the measures likely to exclude or prohibit the activities of service providers or, in the present instance, those of users wishing to self-handle, even if they apply without distinction to national service providers or users and to those in other Member States, must be justified by overriding public-interest requirements and not by economic factors and must, moreover, be in proportion to the aims pursued.

1.2. Procedure

The German authorities undertook to make the entry into force of the exemption decision subject to the Commission's decision.

As pointed out in its two decisions on the airports at Frankfurt and Dusseldorf (8), the Commission's examination must address:

–

the existence and scope of the constraints justifying the exemption and the inability to provide openings to the extent provided for by the Directive; only space and/or capacity constraints may be taken into account;

–

the plan of the appropriate action that is intended to overcome those constraints; that plan must be credible and unconditional and include a timetable for the implementation of those measures;