The aim of the exemption is therefore to preserve the status quo regarding self-handling. On the other hand, from 1 January 1999, a second supplier will be allowed to provide services to third parties where the airport managing body was the sole supplier for those services on the date of notification, so ensuring the minimum choice required by Article 6 of the Directive as regards groundhandling services to third parties.
CONSTRAINTS REFERRED TO BY THE GERMAN AUTHORITIES
The exemption is based on the airport's current space problems which will be aggravated by the substantial works to be carried out in the coming years and the particular difficulties to be expected with the arrival of new baggage handling operators. According to the German authorities, the available space should be sufficient for a second service provider but not also for additional self-handling users.
It is based mainly on the dossier prepared by the airport and presented by Gleiss, Lutz, Hootz & Hirsch as well as the study by Professor Heimerl 'Kapazität der Anlagen des Flughafen Stuttgart` (Capacity of facilities at Stuttgart airport).
Problems with equipment parking
According to the German authorities, these problems are serious in two areas.
1.1. Available space
Firstly, only four of the 39 aircraft positions allow gate parking. A fifth should be added when the extension to Terminal 1 is complete. Of the many remaining positions, 18 require pusher tugs to be used to move the aircraft (point 5.6 of the Annex to the Directive). These are the positions located along the installations on the north side of the airport. These tugs are heavy, quite difficult to park, and must stay near the positions.
Similarly, the large number of distant positions require the use of many shuttle buses to carry passengers and sufficient trolleys to ensure that baggage is moved fast enough over long distances (point 5.4 of the Annex).
While equipment can be parked at the head of aircraft for positions located along the installations on the north side, the German authorities consider that this cannot be done for positions on the tarmac on the south side, since they are already very close to taxiway N, at the minimum safety distance. Moreover, at night, nearly all the positions would be used to park aircraft, thus preventing their temporary use as equipment parking areas.
1.2. Safety