Recital 40, Decision_act (EU) 1998/388

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

The German authorities do not refer explicitly to the question of whether their decision conforms to the criteria laid down in Article 9(2) of the Directive, including whether the measures taken are appropriate to the existing constraints. These measures concern, first, certain ramp handling operations such as the moving, loading and unloading of the aircraft as well as the airside transport of passengers and freight which require heavy and bulky equipment, and secondly the external and internal cleaning of the aircraft and aircraft services including the removal of snow and ice and de-icing, for which specialist equipment is required. As regards the external and internal cleaning of the aircraft, the airport has created no monopoly for itself but is taking account of the principles of the Directive by opening up the market to a minimum of two suppliers and two self-handling users. Given the present situation airside, the Commission considers that the space available would not at present allow the opening-up of the market to the degree provided for by the Directive, so that the decision of the German authorities is commensurate to the constraints. Similarly, the decision does not appear disproportionate as regards the services affected.