The Commission must therefore verify whether it is impossible to open up the market to the degree provided for in the Directive, and must cover the following three points:
the existence and extent of the space and capacity constraints alleged by the German authorities,
the plan of appropriate solutions, which has to be acceptable from the point of view both of the measures to be taken by the airport and the timetable for their implementation. On this point, the Commission considers that the airport or Member State must commit itself even more rigorously to appropriate measures if the exemption limits access to the market. In the case of the exemption for Düsseldorf airport, this applies to the part which permits the maintenance of a complete monopoly for certain ramp-handling operations for which airport users have neither a choice between several suppliers nor the option of self-handling,
conformity with the criteria referred to in Article 9(2) of the Directive.
In accordance with Article 9(4) of the Directive, the Commission has made a detailed analysis of the alleged space and capacity constraints, considering whether the decision taken is appropriate to those constraints and examined the measures to overcome them. In carrying out this task, it has received technical assistance from Alan Stratford and Associates.
B. Space and capacity constraints
Structural space problems at the airport