Recital 19, Decision_act (EU) 1998/388

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

An exemption can be granted only on the basis of specific space or capacity constraints. These constraints must be sufficiently important to make it impossible to open up the market to the degree provided for in the Directive. Moreover, Article 9(2) of the Directive expressly lays down that the exemption granted must not unduly prejudice the aims of the Directive, give rise to distortions of competition or extend further than necessary. Finally, as the Court has already indicated in a number of cases, and in particular in its judgments of 20 April 1978 in Joined Cases 80-81/77, Commissionnaires réunis v. Receveur des Douanes (3) and of 25 June 1992 in Case C 116/91, British Gas (4), an exemption should not be interpreted in such a way as to extend its effects beyond what is necessary to achieve the intended protection of interests. The Commission must therefore make a strict examination of the exemption. On the basis of Article 9(1)(a) and (c), the Member State in question may therefore limit to a minimum of two the number of suppliers or self handling users for those categories of services to which access is completely free. It is on this basis that the exemption limits to two the number of suppliers and users authorised to carry out aircraft cleaning and service operations.

  • Judgment of the Court of 20 April 1978. Société Les Commissionnaires Réunis SARL v Receveur des douanes ; SARL Les fils de Henri Ramel v RecDecision

    20 Apr 1978 · 61977CJ0080

  • Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 25 June 1992. Licensing Authority South Eastern Traffic Area v British Gas plc.Decision

    25 Jun 1992 · 61991CJ0116