Recital 37, Decision_act (EU) 1995/551

In force

The Commission does not share SCK's view. It has not been established that the SCK certification system does provide real added value over and above the statutory rules applicable. The requirements imposed on the affiliated firms are virtually identical to the statutory ones, particularly where tax and social security provisions and compliance with safety rules are concerned (see point 11). This was explicitly recognized by SCK in its notification. SCK observed in particular that 'it intends only to ensure that a certified firm can demonstrate that it meets the statutory requirements` (1).

It is the responsibility of the authorities to ensure compliance with such statutory provisions by all firms, whether or not they participate in the system; see the judgment of the Court of First Instance of the European Communities in Case T-30/89, Hilti AG v. Commission (2). The complainants have handed over documents to the Commission from which it is clear that firms which do not participate in the SCK certification system can likewise demonstrate that they meet the statutory requirements. The Commission is entirely convinced that the restrictions imposed on affiliated firms and the disadvantages which result for non-affiliated firms clearly outweigh any advantages claimed by SCK.

Most of the safety requirements which SCK imposes for certifying a crane-hire firm are also imposed by the safety decrees based on the Law on Conditions at the Workplace (Arbowet) and by the various ministerial regulations. Official supervision of compliance with such provisions is carried out by KeBoMa and the Labour Inspectorate in particular. Similarly, most of the non-safety-related requirements which SCK imposes, such as those relating to the payment of tax and social security contributions, registration with the Chamber of Commerce, third-party insurance, creditworthiness and application of the collective labour agreement, are already covered by statutory provisions. SCK goes beyond statute law by imposing requirements regarding the manner of conducting business, but that alone is insufficient to justify the restrictions of competition imposed.

Even if the advantages claimed by SCK for the certification system should outweigh the disadvantages thereof for non-affiliated firms, it has still not been shown that the SCK certification system could not function without the 'inhuurverbod`. The system has in fact functioned without the 'inhuurverbod` since 4 November 1993 (see point (11)). The 'inhuurverbod` is, accordcing to SCK, prescribed by paragraph 2.5 of the Certification Council's recognition criteria, which is derived from the ISO standards for quality systems. Yet paragraph 2.5 offers three ways of monitoring the quality of the supplier firm, in this case the crane-hire firm hiring extra cranes. It makes it possible, inter alia, for the latter itself, as the principal, to judge on its own responsibility whether another crane-hire company called in meets the statutory quality requirements - for example, by the submission of testing certificates, a lifting certificate, etc. In this way, a crane-hire company which, for whatever reasons, does not wish to be affiliated to SCK still has access to the market in principle, and quality does not suffer.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber) of 12 December 1991. Hilti AG v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    12 Dec 1991 · 61989TJ0030

  • case:eu=T-30/87