Recital 19, Decision_act (EU) 1995/551

In force

The crane-hire firms certified by SCK are also undertakings within the meaning of Article 85 (1).

Participation in the SCK system, which involves acceptance of the statutes and rules, therefore constitutes an agreement and/or a decision by an association of undertakings within the meaning of Article 85 (1).

Restrictions of competition Recommended and internal rates (FNK) (20) Prior to the national court's judgment of 11 February 1992, FNK's members were obliged to charge 'reasonable` rates for the hiring of cranes. To this end, FNK published cost calculations and recommended rates based on them (1). These rates and the rates which crane-hire companies charge each other for the hiring of extra cranes were regularly discussed by companies hiring out cranes of certain categories. As is clear from point 10, FNK was involved in those discussions. The jointly recommended prices, which may or may not have been observed in practice, make it possible to predict with reasonable certainty what the pricing policy of competitors would be. Even if, as FNK maintains, it should be left to the crane-hire companies to interpret the concept 'reasonable`, which incidentally is nowhere apparent, it is still established that the reasonability of rates was discussed between the crane-hire companies and FNK. FNK's assertion that only recommended rates 'for internal use` were involved does not alter the fact that FNK members were obliged under Article 3 (b) of the internal rules to charge 'reasonable` rates. The FNK claim that crane-hire companies were 'completely free` when setting their rates is therefore inaccurate. Under Article 3 (c) of the same rules, FNK members have to apply the general conditions drawn up by FNK, in which reference is made to the FNK recommended rates. Under Article 10 (1) (d) of the statutes, expulsion may follow where a member acts in breach of, inter alia, the internal rules. For this reason, the system of recommended and internal rates, which is intended to give substance to the concept of 'reasonable rates`, falls, in accordance with the Commission's decisions and the case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Communities, and in particular its judgments in Case 8/72, Vereeniging van Cementhandelaren v. Commission and in Case 45/85, Verband der Sachversicherer v. Commission (2), within the scope of Article 85 (1) of the Treaty.

  • Judgment of the Court of 17 October 1972. Vereeniging van Cementhandelaren v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    17 Oct 1972 · 61972CJ0008

  • Judgment of the Court of 27 January 1987. Verband der Sachversicherer e.V. v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    27 Jan 1987 · 61985CJ0045