This argument is without foundation in law. The Commission is of course obliged to disclose the documents necessary to ensure that the addresses of a statement of objections are heard effectively on the matters alleged against them. In its judgment in Case T-7/89, Hercules v. Commission (18), the Court of First Instance held that the obligation of disclosure extends to documents which might be exculpatory. There is, however, no provision either in Regulation No 17 or the case law of the Court of Justice or the Court of First Instance which requires the Commission to make general disclosure of all the unused documentation in its possession irrespective of its relevance to the objections raised against the undertakings. On the contrary, the Commission is subject to certain obligations of confidentiality; under Article 20 (2) of Regulation No 17, it may not disclose information acquired as a result of the application of that Regulation and of the kind covered by the obligation of professional secrecy. This obligation is expressly without prejudice to the provision of Article 19 concerning the right to be heard. As the Court of Justice has observed (Case 85/76, Hoffmann-la Roche v. Commission (19), the corollary of the Commission's wide powers to obtain documents from undertakings under Regulation No 17 is the guarantee that the information will not be disclosed to others except in so far as it is necessary to ensure their right to be heard.
Recital 123, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601
In forcesince 13 Jul 1994
Judgment of the Court of 13 February 1979. Hoffmann-La Roche & Co. AG v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
13 Feb 1979 · 61976CJ0085
Judgment of the Court of First Instance (First Chamber) of 17 December 1991. SA Hercules Chemicals NV v Commission of the European CommunitiDecision
17 Dec 1991 · 61989TJ0007