Recital 72, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

With the improvement in the supply-demand balance and the reorganization of its various bodies, the collusion on pricing in the PG Paperboard was to prove more effective than in the years before 1987.

Rather than allowing prices to rise naturally in accordance with market conditions, the method used to increase the price level across the whole of western Europe involved the planning and implementation of concerted 'price initiatives'. The price was raised in a series of regular and clearly defined 'steps'. It is clear from the documentary evidence found by the Commission that the issues of price increases and of volume control are two inextricably linked aspects of the same plan. On the basis of the preparatory work done in the JMC, the PWG took the decisions in principle on the timing and the amount of the increase. Given the natural ordering and consumption patterns of cartonboard customers, the normal practice was for price increases to come into effect in April and October. On occasion, and depending upon market conditions, a price increase might apply to GC grades only and not to GD; the producers were, however, concerned as a general rule to maintain the price differential (30 to 40 %) between the two grades at approximately the same level. A price increase might also be delayed or not even apply in a particular national market (e.g. the second increase of 1988 excluded the United Kingdom except for SBS).

The JMC discussed for each national market the detailed implementation of the broad decision taken in the PWG. The new 'list' prices for each category of customers ('AA', 'A', 'B', 'C' and 'D' in descending order of importance) were agreed in each national currency using a standard grade and weight as a reference. The new prices to be charged to the individual major customers were also discussed in the JMC. Separate reports were made to the PWG for GC and GD grades, and if any difficulties were foreseen the PWG would then seek to resolve the problem.

The documentation obtained by the Commission (see especially recitals 79, 80 and 83) confirms that price increases and the date they came into effect were fixed by the PG Paperboard for Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and Spain, as well as for the EFTA countries.

One of the principal tasks of the JMC was to achieve an 'equivalent' European pricing system, i.e. a uniform price level across the Community. When the concerted price initiatives were relaunched in late 1987 to early 1988, they started from different levels in different national markets. As a result, some divergences occurred. Over the period up to 1991 those divergences were reduced.