M-M had been one of the first producers to implement the March 1988 price increase (already announced in December 1987) as well as the second increase of that year which took effect in October. It had made the sacrifices required of it and lost tonnage in high price markets. M-M's firm attitude on price had made some regular customers unhappy. On the other hand, the marketing manager suspected that not all the other producers had been such firm supporters of the price initiatives as had M-M. Their sales personnel behaved in the market place in a manner different from that which had been agreed at the top level. Citing an example of where another producer had underquoted M-M at a major customer by DM 150 per tonne, he asked rhetorically how such behaviour could fit into the 'agreed system'. He therefore urged his superior (who attended the PWG meetings) to 'swear in' the other producers to abide by the same rigid rule as that imposed on M-M, i.e. turn away business rather than break the agreed price.
The Commission attempted to obtain from M-M further details of the precise circumstances of the agreement which had been made between the cartonboard producers in 1987.
In its reply under Article 11 M-M claimed that there was no agreement 'in the strict sense' and that the repeated use in the memorandum in question of this term (and similar expressions) by its marketing manager should not be 'taken literally'.