Recital 121, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

The special position of Enso-Gutzeit (see recital 119) is perhaps explicable in terms of its being the only major European cartonboard producer manufacturing exclusively SBS grades. It claims that its involvement in the PG Paperboard was innocent and only sporadic. It only went to President Conferences, and was the sole producer which never attended any meetings of the JMC. The Commission does not however rely simply as proof of its participation in the infringement on its attendance at President Conferences. Further proof of its involvement is provided inter alia by its membership of both the Board and the Marketing Committee of the NPI, a body whose role in collusion is amply demonstrated; its attendance at the Arlanda meeting noted by Rena (recital 58); the various references in the Iggesund note on the price increase of April 1990 (recital 97); and its own commercial documentation which (in so far as it is available) shows not only a continuing pattern of price increases identical to those of the other major SBS producer, Iggesunds Bruk, but also, for October 1989, a virtually exact correspondence to the NPI price list obtained from Rena (recital 80). The cumulative effect of these different items of both direct and circumstantial evidence is such that there is no reasonable doubt as to Enso-Gutzeit's involvement in a system of collusion.

I.

PROCEDURAL ISSUES (122) In the course of the procedure two producers, namely MoDo and De Eendracht, claimed that the Commission had infringed their rights of defence by failing to grant them full access to its administrative files.

MoDo's allegation was couched in very general terms and during the oral hearing its legal representative admitted that in reality it could point to no example of the Commission having withheld from it any document or material which might be relevant to its right to be heard.

De Eendracht's argument related solely to the Commission's having declined to disclose to it the full file of meetings and correspondence of ACBM (recitals 98 and 99), a body of which it was not a member. The Commission had annexed to the statement of objections sent to all producers, including De Eendracht, the documentation in its possession relating to the matters concerning the ACBM referred to in recitals 98 and 99. It declined, however, to permit the representatives of De Eendracht to peruse on a speculative basis the other records of the ACBM. De Eendracht insisted in this connection that the Commission was obliged to disclose to it all documents in its possession obtained during the course of the investigation from other undertakings apart from those containing business secrets and for which confidentiality had been expressly claimed by the owner.