Membership of the PG Paperboard (and especially of the PWG, JMC or both) is not, however, by any means the only evidence available of individual participation in the cartel. Further evidence of the participation of each undertaking in the infringement is provided by a combination of some or all of the following elements:
explicit references to that undertaking in the cartel documents obtained from FS-Karton, Rena or Cascades,
incriminating references in the PAA documents,
participation in concerted price initiatives,
internal documentation of that undertaking or another undertaking linking it to collusion.
The full details of the evidence proving the participation of each undertaking in the cartel were provided to each undertaking in the form of individual particulars sent with the principal statement of objections together with schedules showing the implementation of the price increases. In no significant respect was any of that evidence contradicted or shown to be anything but reliable during the administrative procedure.