Recital 119, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

The participation of each producer in the cartel can be established prima facie by its membership of the PG Paperboard and participation in its various committees. In most cases this is not denied. The participation in each group of the PG Paperboard is shown in Table 7.

The PG Paperboard itself had a predominantly unlawful purpose. It also had certain legitimate activities but no 'bright line' can be drawn between the 'legal' and 'illegal' groupings inside the organization. The PWG and JMC were almost entirely concerned with price fixing and market sharing and appear to have had little or no redeeming features. The Economic Committee may have been less directly concerned with price fixing as such but it is not credible that those who attended were unaware of the illicit purpose for which the information they knowingly provided to the JMC was to be used. In any case, the private note made by M-M of 'highlights' of the meeting in October 1989 makes the link with price initiatives abundantly clear. The President Conference received reports from the PWG and its members were told the prices to apply, and so they cannot have been ignorant of what was happening in the other committees of the PG Paperboard.

With the sole exception of Enso-Gutzeit, all the undertakings to which this Decision is addressed were in fact members of the JMC (and in the case of the major producers, of the PWG as well).