Recital 124, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

Contrary to De Eendracht's arguments, the Commission's qualified obligation of professional secrecy under Article 20 (2) does not relate only to information falling within the extremely narrow category of 'trade secret' which requires special protection. The two concepts - of professional secrecy and trade secrets - are entirely different in nature and purpose, and their application has completely different results. The obligation of professional secrecy to which the Commission and its officials are subject by virtue of Article 20 (2) embodies the general legal principle of confidentiality. It covers all information obtained from undertakings under Regulation No 7 except that which is so trivial that it is not worthy of confidentiality.

In the present case, the unused documentation relating to the ACBM consists principally of records of meetings which took place in private between members of a group of which De Eendracht was not a member and for which confidentiality should in principle be maintained unless good cause is shown. The Commission did in fact annex to the statement of objections a number of ACBM documents, (as well as those relating to the PAA) which were relevant to the issue of the implementation in national markets of the pricing discussion of the PG Paperboard. It should be noted that De Eendracht declined to comment at all in its written observations not only on those ACBM documents but also on those of the PAA in which its United Kingdom selling agent participated. De Eendracht has not identified any issue of fact or law in respect of which disclosure to it of the full set of ACBM documents may have been necessary or desirable. None of the members of the ACBM (to which the full ACBM file was made available) has put forward any argument on the basis of documents not annexed to the statement of objections. It is not therefore immediately apparent how the internal documents of the ACBM which were not relevant to the suspected infringement could have been in any way relevant to any possible defence of De Eendracht.