Even without the documentary evidence of collusion and Stora's detailed statements, the uniformity of the price increases announced by the cartonboard producers and the simultaneity of their introduction in each west European national market over a period of several years are so striking that on this basis alone the inference of prior collusion would have been almost inescapable.
Coupled with the incriminating documents obtained from several different sources, particularly M-M/FS-Karton, Cascades and Rena, the long-run pattern of industry price initiatives between 1987 and 1991 leaves no doubt whatever that the price increases were planned, organized and monitored by a European cartel of producers.
A particular feature of the documentary evidence obtained by the Commission in the present case is that each major item of proof is supported and corroborated by documents found at other producers. The statement made by Stora is confirmed in every significant respect by the documents found at (or provided by) FS-Karton, Cascades, Finnboard, Rena and several others. The argument of some (but not all) producers that the meetings of the Presidents and the JMC were concerned only with innocent matters can therefore be dismissed as entirely fanciful. The only records obtained of JMC meetings are entirely unambiguous as to their purpose and content. Although all the notes of JMC meetings obtained by the Commission related to GC grades, they can in the absence of any other record be taken as typical of meetings held for GD, as well as of the subject matter of the JMC meetings in general. Indeed in answer to questions during the oral hearing, the representative of M-M admitted that the incriminating notes were a representative sample of what occurred in these meetings. M-M's private note of the Economic Committee of 3 October 1989 may also be taken as indicative of the real nature of the deliberations of that body.