Recital 29, Decision_act (EU) 1994/272

In force

In order to qualify for exemption, FNK and SCK must, inter alia, show that the agreements or decisions by associations of undertakings contribute to improving the crane-hire business while allowing consumers a fair share of the resulting benefit. The improvement must entail objective and appreciable advantages such as to compensate for any disadvantages they cause in the field of competition (4).

The requirements imposed on members and affiliated firms are virtually identical to the statutory requirements applicable, particularly as regards tax and social security provisions on the one hand and compliance with safety rules on the other (see recital 11).

It is the responsibility of the authorities to ensure compliance with such statutory provisions by all undertakings, whether or not they participate in the system (5). It is therefore hard to see how any measurable benefits can result from the system. The conclusion must therefore be that the restrictions imposed on affiliated firms and the resulting disadvantages for non-affiliated firms are merely designed to coerce crane-hire firms to join a cartel. The disadvantages thus clearly outweigh any benefits claimed by FNK and SCK. Furthermore, the restrictions imposed by FNK and SCK are not indispensable to the attainment of their objectives as set out in their statutes, since they merely duplicate the monitoring of compliance with Dutch statutory provisions.

Most of the safety requirements which SCK imposes for certifying a crane-hire firm are also imposed by the safety decrees based on the Law on conditions at the workplace and by the various ministerial regulations. Official supervision of compliance with such provisions is carried out by KeBoMa in particular. Similarly, most of the non-safety-related requirements which SCK imposes, such as those relating to the payment of tax and social security contributions, registration with the Chamber of Commerce, third-party insurance, creditworthiness and application of the collective labour agreement, are already covered by statutory provisions. SCK goes beyond the statutory requirements by imposing requirements regarding the manner of conducting business, but that alone is insufficient reason to regard the restrictions of competition imposed as indispensable.

Rather, it would seem that the restrictions imposed by FNK and SCK are aimed at excluding other undertakings and at sharing markets in the Netherlands, thereby eliminating competition in respect of a substantial part of the crane-hire market. In particular competition from firms in other Member States is in effect eliminated (see recital 25).