Under its statutes, SCK's object is to promote and maintain the quality of crane-hire firms. The objective is to be attained through the establishment of a code of conduct, through a certification system and through monitoring arrangements to ensure compliance with the code of conduct. Certification involves the monitoring of a number of aspects of the crane-hire firm itself: compliance with legal requirements concerning tax and social security payments; evidence of insurance cover, creditworthiness and liquidity; the skills and conditions of employment of the staff. It also involves checking that the firm is on the trade register of the Chamber of Commerce, which excludes or at least seriously impedes access for firms from outside the Netherlands. Certification also covers technical aspects of the cranes themselves, although SCK does not itself inspect any cranes. The cranes are provided with certification plates by SCK to show that the statutory conditions have been complied with. Finally, certified firms are obliged to apply FNK's general conditions. These include conditions concerning prices.
Certification is carried out by members of the advisory body and the certification committee. Members drawn from the sector that awards contracts to crane-hire firms are prominently represented on these SCK bodies. For example, AKZO, DSM and Shell have representatives on the SCK bodies. Firms placing such contracts are thus encouraged to award them to certified firms. The system is made watertight by the abovementioned 'inhuurverbod' which entered into force on 1 January 1991, under which the certified firm is not allowed to hire extra cranes from firms that are not affiliated to SCK. Since a lot of work in the sector is carried out on a subcontracting basis, the likely effect has been a significant decrease in the turnover of non-affiliated firms; this has already placed a number of such firms in difficulties.
The course of the proceeding (12) Following preliminary examination of the case, the Commission issued its statement of objections on 16 December 1992. The Commission considered withdrawing, pursuant to Article 15 (6) of Regulation No 17, the immunity against fines provided for in Article 15 (5) of the Regulation, since it is of the opinion that Article 85 (1) of the Treaty has clearly been infringed and that application of Article 85 (3) is not justified, principally because SCK prohibits its participants from hiring cranes from non-affiliated firms and excludes the affiliation of foreign firms. This ban on hiring extra cranes from non-affiliated firms has far-reaching consequences, particularly in view of the clear involvement in FNK and SCK of large firms that regularly and frequently award contracts to crane-hire firms, which places SCK participants in an extremely favourable position.
The facts and arguments adduced by FNK and SCK in their reply of 3 February 1993 to the statement of objections did not provide any grounds for the Commission to change its views on SCK's certification system, and in particular the ban on the hiring of extra cranes from non-affiliated firms.
In its letter of 4 June 1993 the Commission informed FNK and SCK of this. The Commission indicated that the procedure pursuant to Article 15 (6) of Regulation No 17 could be terminated only if FNK and SCK decided to withdraw the ban.