Recital 13, Decision_act (EU) 1994/272

In force

In response, FNK and SCK proposed, in their letter of 12 July 1993, that the ban on the hire of extra cranes from non-affiliated firms, as set out in the second indent of Article 7 of the rules, should be amended in such a way that only cranes could be employed which were provided with valid proof of certification granted either by SCK 'or by another certification institution which is qualified under EN 45011 to certify crane-hire firms and in so doing applies demonstrably equivalent criteria.'

The Commission considers that this proposal does not meet its objections, since it has not been established that a private-law certification system such as that introduced by SCK adds anything essential to the already existing statutory requirements applying to cranes and lifting equipment. All such machines and parts thereof are, moreover, covered by the abovementioned Directive 89/392/EEC. In addition, KeBoMA, the crane inspection body recognized by the Dutch Government, does not rank as a certification institution qualified under EN 45011, with the result that cranes which have only KeBoMa approval and which thus satisfy all statutory requirements are still caught by the ban. The amendment proposed by FNK and SCK will consequently have little or no effect in practice.

The Commission thereupon proposed, in a letter dated 2 August 1993, that the second indent of Article 7 of the rules should be amended in such a way as to allow the use only of cranes which can be shown to comply with the statutory provisions in force in the place where the user has his registered office. FNK and SCK did not accept this proposal. The Commission thereupon decided to continue the proceeding pursuant to Article 15 (6).

The course of the proceeding before the national court (14) In an interlocutory judgment delivered on 11 February 1992 the President of the Utrecht District Court, in proceedings brought by Van Marwijk and others, ordered SCK to suspend application of the ban. This judgment was overturned, similarly in interlocutory proceedings, on 9 July 1992 by the Amsterdam Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal took the view that its was not for the time being evident and beyond all doubt that the arrangements in question did not have any chance of being exempted by the Commission. In the view of the Court of Appeal, a national court had to be careful in delivering any judgment in the matter, especially since the arrangements were now subject to the decision to be taken by the Commission.

  • celex=31989L0392