, Decision_act (EU) 1993/564

In forcesince 22 Jul 1993

Although it had never approved Provincial law No 7/91 as such, the Commission considered that the Italian Government could notify a particular application of that law pursuant to Article 93 (3) of the Treaty, in the same way as it might notify an ad hoc aid. On the basis of the information made available to it, the Commission held the opinion that the intervention proposed by the PAT in favour of Cartiere del Garda could constitute aid, as it would allow the company to invest at Mori without having to bear all the cost thereof. Cartiere del Garda had had a study commissioned in order to identify and quantify this additional cost. The cost had then been investigated by the Mediocredito bank on behalf of the PAT. Whereas Cartiere del Garda arrived at an extra investment cost of Lit 316 billion and an extra operating cost in the first five years of Lit 197 billion, the PAT calculated the extra investment cost at Lit 173 377 million and operating cost at Lit 148 560 million. In view of the uncertainties in indentifying the additional cost, the PAT considered using the option offered by Provincial law No 7/91 of paying as a lump sum 30 % of total investment cost at Mori, which would amount to Lit 186 billion.

The Commission also held the opinion that this presumed aid of up to Lit 186 billion would be likely to distort competition and to affect trade between Member States within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty.

The Commission furthermore doubted whether any of the derogations set out in Article 92 could apply to the aid. It noted that neither Riva nor Mori is located in an area eligible for regional assistance pursuant to Article 92 (3) (a) or (c) and that the aid could be potentially anti-cohesive by excluding other potential sites in assisted areas from the investment in question. The Commission also noted that an aid for an expansion of capacity does not meet the conditions set out in the Community framework for environmental aids, which is based on the derogation provided for in Article 92 (3) (b) of the Treaty. The Commission furthermore doubted whether the derogation provided for in Article 92 (3) (c) could apply; it doubted whether the aid was necessary to achieve the desired objective of dissuading Cartiere del Garda from making its investment at Riva, and it stressed the situation of overcapacity for coated paper in the Community.