, Decision_act (EU) 1993/564

In forcesince 22 Jul 1993

IV A payment by public authorities to a company in order to cover part of the investment cost of that company at a given site constitutes aid to that company within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty. It is irrelevant to this appraisal whether the investment cost at some other site would have been lower and the payment only amounts to the difference between the investment cost at those two sites. The assessment that such payments constitute aid is in line with the well-established practice of the Commission concerning payments to companies which accept additional cost by investing in less-favoured regions or which assume additional investment cost in order to modify their existing installations for environmental reasons.

Consequently, the intention of the PAT to pay Lit 173 377 million (ECU 103 million as at the date of this Decision) to Cartiere del Garda if that company should decide to invest at Mori rather than at Riva constitutes aid to that company, even though this sum only represents the additional investment cost which an investment at Mori would entail. The company is favoured by that aid, because it is enabled to carry out its investment at Mori without having to bear all the cost thereof.

There is competition between manufacturers of paper and their products are traded between Member States. According to the information submitted to the Commission, Cartiere del Garda at present produces some 175 000 tonnes annually of medium-weight and heavy coated wood-containing and wood-free printing paper. The installation of an additional paper-making machine at Mori or at Riva would double the company's productive capacity from 180-200 000 tonnes per year to some 400 000 tonnes per year.

Italy exported 532 320 tonnes of coated paper and paperboard (CN code 4810) to other Member States in 1990, 572 877 tonnes in 1991 and 596 278 tonnes in 1992, while the corresponding imports from other Member States amounted to 200 531, 195 586 and 238 535 tonnes.