Recital 55, Decision_act (EU) 1992/157

In forcesince 17 Feb 1992

As to the possibility of interfering with the retail activity of dealers or parallel importers, the Exchange entails the following potential anticompetitive effects:

–

the dealer import and dealer export analyses show for each dealer territory the exact number of sales made to customers within that territory both by the local dealer and by other dealers of the same network. These analyses further show in which dealer territories outside his own a dealer makes sales. The Exchange thus reveals the exact destination of each specific tractor and reveals the export activities of each dealer into the territories of other dealers in the United Kingdom. This monitoring of dealers' sales outside their allocated territory allows manufacturers to exercise pressure on dealers engaging in any perceived excessive export activity. It is the very nature of such reports to give rise to misuse which in most cases cannot be controlled a posteriori (a manufacturer could, for instance, reduce supplies to a dealer who sells too many tractors in other dealers' territories). The import/export analyses are thus highly likely to reduce intrabrand competition with the result that dealers can maintain higher profit margins for both themselves and the manufacturers,

–

until September 1988, the members of the Exchange also received from SIL a copy of each V55 registration form which enabled manufacturers to identify parallel imported tractors and to trace the origin of these tractors (see recitals (27) to (30)). The documents referred to in recital (30) show that the information made available to each member has been used to stop parallel imports of tractors from other Community countries into the United Kingdom. The Exchange was thus a facilitating mechanism for interference with parallel imports which brought about competitive pressure on the United Kingdom dealerships.