Recital 50, Decision_act (EU) 1992/157

In forcesince 17 Feb 1992

The parties have further submitted that the information relates only to past transactions as opposed to future planned actions. Therefore, in their view the exchanged information is historical information which has no impact on competition in the market concerned. This argument cannot be accepted either.

In a market where demand is stable or declining as is the case for the agricultural tractor market in the United Kingdom, forecasts of competitors' future actions can largely be determined on the basis of past transactions. All the restrictive effects of the Exchange described above depend on the observation of competitors' actions and performance in the past. The more accurate and the more recent the information on quantities sold and on market shares, the more impact this information has on future behaviour of the firms in the market (see the judgment of the Court of Justice in Case 172/80, Zuechner v. Bayerische Vereinsbank AG [1981] ECR, p. 2021 (10)).

However, the Commission accepts that from a certain point in time, market information relating to past transactions becomes truly historic and no longer has any real impact on future behaviour. In the present case, the Commission considers that an annual exchange of one-year-old sales figures of individual competitors at the United Kingdom, MAFF region and land use level and with a breakdown by model can be accepted as commercial data with no appreciable distorting effect on competition between the manufacturers or between the dealers operating on the United Kingdom market.

  • Judgment of the Court of 14 July 1981. Gerhard Züchner v Bayerische Vereinsbank AG.Decision

    14 Jul 1981 · 61980CJ0172