, Decision_act (EU) 1991/306

In forcesince 12 Dec 1990

In the verbal note of the German Government of 13 February 1990 it was stated that the 90 % guarantee on a DM 1,8 million loan concerned the fulfilment of a building contract for a gravel silo vessel for inland waters, guarantee which was returned four months after its provision. On the 95 % guarantee on a DM 20,7 million loan it was repeated that this guarantee was to be considered as development aid and means to cover the risks not covered by the Hermes-guarantee approved by the Commission in its letter of 9 March 1988. In the verbal note of 2 May 1990 an overview was given of the activities comprised in the 1988, 1989 and 1990 turnovers of the Schiffswerft Germersheim im Konkurs.

II

The fact that the German authorities have withdrawn their notification on the 90 % guarantee on the DM 1,8 million loan because the guarantee had not to be called in during the building process does not prevent the fact that had the notification been made before the guarantee was given, an assessment of this project would have been made under the provisions of Article 92 of the EEC Treaty. The withdrawal of the notification is due to the fact that the aid has served its purpose. Given the fact that the guarantee was necessary for the yard to continue its operation while in serious financial difficulties, the guarantee even has the character of a rescue aid.

Given the fact that the guarantee is related to the building process of a vessel for inland waters, which activity falls outside the scope of the definition of shipbuilding used in Article 1 of Directive 87/167/EEC the aid project of the provision of a 90 % guarantee on a DM 1,8 million loan has to be considered under the provisions of Article 92 of the EEC Treaty.

The provision of a 95 % guarantee on a DM 20,7 million loan in 1989 has to be assessed under the provisions of Directive 87/167/EEC and if this Directive does not apply, it then has to be appraised under the provisions of Article 92 of the EEC Treaty. The general principle of Chapter II of Directive 87/167/EEC is to ensure that aid granted to shipyards and shipowners directly related to contracts together with other operating aid granted to the shipyard can be deemed compatible with the common market as long as the grant equivalent of the aid does not exceed a common maximum aid ceiling expressed as a percentage of the contract value before aid.