However, it is true that according to Article 4 (7) of Directive 87/167/EEC aid related to shipbuilding and ship conversion granted as development assistance to a developing country is not to be subject to the ceiling and may be deemed compatible with the common market if it complies with the terms laid down for that purpose by OECD Working Party No 6 in its agreement concerning the interpretation of Articles 6 to 8 of the OECD Council resolution of 3 August 1981. This agreement only provides for the grant of aid in the form of export credits on certain terms and does not envisage the grant of guarantees. The aim of Article 4 (7) of the Directive is to allow aid to reduce the price of ships to certain developing countries in specific circumstances and not to grant rescue aid to yards in the Community. For this reason while the Commission approved on 9 March 1988 the aid element contained in the soft credit conditions in the ferry contract with Senegal it cannot consider that the grant of a guarantee comes under Article 4 (7) since a guarantee to a shipyard provides aid to that yard which should normally be assessed under Articles 4 (1) and 5 of the Directive.
The fact that a subsequent 95 % guarantee on a DM 20,7 million loan is needed during a period of financial difficulties to ensure the continuance of the yard's activities, including the building process of a development project, does not imply that development aid within the meaning of Article 4 (7) of Directive 87/167/EEC is concerned. The development aid notified and approved by the Commission for the ferry for Senegal only made reference to credit conditions for Senegal and not to possible production aid granted later to the yard in order to make it capable of completing the ship for the recipient in Senegal.
Since financing costs during the building process are a normal part of the cost price, for which part public support is not common practice, it is clear that this guarantee is ordinary production aid which became necessary on account of the financial difficulties of the yard. The fact that after no bank was found willing to grant the loan, as it was only covered by a 90 % guarantee, the guarantee had to be raised to the present 95 % conclusively proves the point that this 95 % guarantee on a DM 20,7 million loan represents operating aid.