As it appeared that the Schiffswerft Germersheim was in a state of bankruptcy the Commission asked the German Government to confirm this legal situation and to specify details concerning the bankruptcy, the future prospects of the Germersheimer Werft and a breakdown of the yard's turnover figures for 1988 and 1989 to enable the Commission to calculate an aid equivalent.
As it appeared that the German Government in its letter of 25 July 1989 stated that it withdrew the notification of the 95 % guarantee on the DM 1,8 million loan and did not provide sufficient information on the different activities that formed part of the total turnover of the yard, information which was also lacking in the German Government's verbal note of 3 August 1989, the Commission by letter of 8 September 1989 asked the German Government again to specify details on the state of bankruptcy and the content of ocean-going shipbuilding in the company's total turnover figures. In the German Government's verbal note of 3 August 1989 it was stated that the second aid project, i.e. the 95 % guarantee on the DM 20,7 million loan was to be considered as development aid.
The Schiffswerft Germersheim filed a claim for legal settlement with creditors on 25 November 1988, after which the Amtsgericht Landau declared the state of bankruptcy on 17 January 1989. It appears that from some stage in spring 1989 onwards sites and facilities of the yard were used by the Schiffswerft Germersheim im Konkurs as well as by the newly founded Auffangesellschaft Neue Schiffswerft Germersheim.
By telecopies of 24 and 31 May 1989, a competitor raised a complaint to the Commission, criticising the foundation of the new company by the trustee of the Schiffswerft Germersheim and the rescue aid granted to the yard which would not have been in line with Council Regulation (EEC) No 1101/89 of 27 April 1989 on structural improvements in waterway transport (2).
Since in the German Government's verbal notes of 17 October and 27 November 1989 all the requested information about the shipbuilding activities of the company had not been given, the Commission initiated the Article 93 (2) procedure by letter SG(89) D/000014 of 4 January 1990 in respect of the two abovementioned guarantees for the companies using the site and facilities of the former Schiffswerft Germersheim.
No other Member State or interested party reacted on the publication of this decision in the Official Journal of the European Communities (3).