, Decision_act (EU) 1990/70

In forcesince 28 Jun 1989

In reaching its decision, the Commission noted that the aid related to costs connected with the workforce (FF 1 619,2 million), direct restructuring costs (FF 641,9 million), the completion of contracts after closure (FF 489,2 million), the writing-off of losses (FF 68 million) and investment (FF 301 million), with the remainder still having to be specified (FF 116,8 million). It explained that it had not been able to establish that the restructuring plans presented in this connection were distinct from those which the Commission had ruled against in its abovementioned Decision 87/506/EEC covering some of the undertakings involved in the present case. Lastly, given the fact that the sectors in question have surplus capacity at Community level, the extent of the aid poses a threat which the Commission cannot overlook that competition might be distorted in a way that is contrary to the common interest.

On 28 September 1988, the Commission also decided to initiate the Article 93 (2) procedure in respect of the aid for the undertakings covered by the second series of notifications. In the first place, it noted that the aid related to costs connected with the workforce (FF 302,3 million), costs associated with closures (FF 112 million) and the settlement of Métalinor's financial liabilities (FF 238 million). This latter heading includes repayments intended for the parent company Usinor Sacilor. The aid could thus distort competition in the ECSC area to an extent contrary to the common interest. Secondly, the Commission wondered why the Government had to act instead of the undertakings concerned, or at any rate of their parent company, in assuming closure costs which are normally for the undertakings themselves to bear.

II

The French authorities presented their comments by letters dated 18 July 1988 and 17 January 1989 with regard to the first proceedings, by letters dated 28 October 1988 and 1 February 1989 with regard to the second proceedings and by letters dated 27 February and 3 March 1989 on both proceedings.

The letters stipulate first that, both as regards the restructuring measures and as regards the financial flows, the new restructuring plans presented are wholly distinct from those underlying the previous measures notified to the Commission, which the Commission declared to be unlawful in its Decision of 25 March 1987.