Annexe 9
Complément luxembourgeois au code d’éthique tel qu’émis par l’International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) dans sa version publiée dans le « Handbook of the International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants – 2023 Edition » de l’International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) (ci-après « le code d’éthique »)
L’objectif du présent complément luxembourgeois au code d’éthique est de compiler les obligations légales et réglementaires qui concernent l’éthique et l’indépendance des réviseurs d’entreprises (« RE »), des réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (« REA »), des cabinets de révision (« CR ») et des cabinets de révision agréés (« CRA ») telles qu’elles proviennent de la loi du 23 juillet 2016 relative à la profession de l’audit d’une part et du Règlement UE Nº 537/2014 du parlement européen et du conseil relatif aux exigences spécifiques applicables au contrôle légal des comptes des entités d’intérêt public (« EIP ») d’autre part et de les rattacher aux sections du code d’éthique correspondantes.
Table of contents
PART 1 - COMPLYING WITH THE CODE, FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
110 The Fundamental Principles
PART 3 - PROFESSIONAL ACCOUNTANTS IN PUBLIC PRACTICE
320 Professional appointments
325 Objectivity of an engagement quality reviewer and other appropriate reviewers
350 Custody of client assets
PART 4A – INDEPENDENCE FOR AUDIT AND REVIEW ENGAGEMENTS
400 Applying the conceptual framework to independence for audit and review engagements (effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning before December 15, 2024)
400 Applying the conceptual framework to independence for audit and review engagements (effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after December 15, 2024)
410 Fees
420 Gifts and hospitality
510 Financial interests
520 Business Relationships
524 Employment with an audit client
540 Long association of senior personnel (including partner rotation) with an audit client
Internal rotation
External rotation
600 Provision of non-assurance services to an audit client
Prohibition to provide non-audit services
List of prohibited non-audit services
Prohibited non-audit services provided by an affiliate within the network to an entity registered in a third-country and under control of the audited public-interest entity
Approval of non-audit services by the audit committees
GLOSSARY
PART 1 - COMPLYING WITH THE CODE, FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
SECTION 110
THE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES
SUBSECTION 115 – PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOR
Paragraph R115.1 is completed as follows:
“The exercise by the réviseur d’entreprises (statutory auditor), the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision (audit firm), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm of one of their respective activities referred to in Article 1(34) of the Audit Law is incompatible with any activity liable to detract from the principles of independence of the profession.
Where he, she exercises the activities referred to in the previous paragraph, the réviseur d’entreprises (statutory auditor) or the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) may not enter paid employment unless it is with a cabinet de révision (audit firm), a cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or an audit firm.” (AL/Article 19)
Paragraph R115.2 is completed as follows:
“A réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or a cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) can advertise or solicit new work for services other than audit engagements that are also offered by other professionals who are not subject to similar standards nor similar ethical rules. Nevertheless, any advertising or solicitation shall be executed in accordance with the principles mentioned in the current section. Advertising or solicitation for audit engagements are strictly forbidden. Factual description of services offered by an audit firm, including audit services, is authorized”.
PART 3 – PROFESSIONAL ACCOUNTANTS IN PUBLIC PRACTICE
SECTION 320
PROFESSIONAL APPOINTMENTS
Requirements
Changes in a Professional Appointment
Changes in Audit or Review Appointments
Paragraph R320.8 is completed as follows:
“The réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) being replaced shall provide the successor with free access to all relevant information concerning the audited entity and the most recent audit of that entity.” [AL/Article 28(5)]
Audit Clients that are Public-Interest Entities
In relation with the handover file in the event of a replacement of an approved statutory auditor (“réviseur d’entreprises agréé”) or approved audit firm (“cabinet de revision agréé”) by a new approved statutory auditor (“réviseur d’entreprises agréé”) or approved audit firm (“cabinet de revision agréé”), paragraph R320.8 is completed as follows:
“Subject to the provisions in relation with the safekeeping of audit documentation, the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) shall also provide the incoming réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) with the previous years’ additional reports to the audit committee and all information communicated to competent authorities, in relation with:
article 12 of Regulation (EU) No 537/2014 (“Report to supervisors of public-interest entities”), applicable in case of (i) a material breach of the laws, regulations or administrative provisions which lay down, where appropriate, the conditions governing authorization or which specifically govern pursuit of the activities of such public-interest entity; (ii) a material threat or doubt concerning the continuous functioning of the public-interest entity; (iii) a refusal to issue an audit opinion on the financial statements or the issuing of an adverse or qualified opinion and
article 13 of Regulation (EU) No 537/2014 (“Transparency report”):
The former réviseur d’entreprises agréé, cabinet de révision agréé or audit firm shall be able to demonstrate to the competent authority that such information has been provided to the incoming statutory auditor or audit firm [AR/Article 18].”
SECTION 325
OBJECTIVITY OF AN ENGAGEMENT QUALITY REVIEWER AND OTHER APPROPRIATE REVIEWERS
General
Paragraph 325.5 A2 is completed as follows:
“For statutory audits of financial statements of public-interest entities, the engagement quality reviewer shall be an approved statutory auditor (« Réviseur d’entreprises Agréé »)”
SECTION 350
CUSTODY OF CLIENT ASSETS
Requirements
Before Taking Custody
Paragraph R350.3 is completed as follows:
“A réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or a cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) shall not assume custody of audited client monies. For a client, other than an audit client, the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) shall inform the concerned credit institution about the nature of the accounts open to hold client monies”.
PART 4A – INDEPENDENCE FOR AUDIT AND REVIEW ENGAGEMENTS
SECTION 400
APPLYING THE CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK TO INDEPENDENCE FOR AUDIT AND REVIEW ENGAGEMENTS
(effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning before December 15, 2024)
Requirements
General
Paragraph R400.16 is completed as follows:
“When carrying out a statutory audit, the réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms), the audit firms, and any natural person in a position to directly or indirectly influence the outcome of the statutory audit, shall be independent of the audited entity. They shall not be involved in the decision-taking of the audited entity.
Independence shall be required at least during both the period covered by the financial statements to be audited and the period during which the statutory audit is carried out.
The réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms) and the audit firms shall take all reasonable steps to ensure that, when carrying out a statutory audit, their independence is not affected by any existing or potential conflict of interest or business or other direct or indirect relationship involving the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm carrying out the statutory audit and, where appropriate, his, her or its network, managers, auditors, employees, any other natural persons whose services are placed at the disposal or under the control of the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm, or any person directly or indirectly linked to the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm by control.
The réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm shall not carry out a statutory audit if there is any threat of self-review, self-interest, advocacy, familiarity or intimidation created by financial, personal, business, employment or other relationships between:
the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm), the audit firm, his, her or its network, and any natural person in a position to influence the outcome of the statutory audit, and
the audited entity,
as a result of which an objective, reasonable and informed third party, taking into account the safeguards applied, would conclude that the independence of the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm is compromised.” [AL/Article 20(1)].
Mergers and acquisitions
When a Client Merger Creates a Threat
In paragraph R400.73 (a), the deadline of six months is shortened to three months [AL/Article 20(6)].
SECTION 400
APPLYING THE CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK TO INDEPENDENCE FOR AUDIT AND REVIEW ENGAGEMENTS
(effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after December 15, 2024)
Introduction
General
Provisions of paragraph 400.14 are repealed.
Requirements
General
Paragraph R400.18 is completed as follows:
“When carrying out a statutory audit, the réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms), the audit firms, and any natural person in a position to directly or indirectly influence the outcome of the statutory audit, shall be independent of the audited entity. They shall not be involved in the decision-taking of the audited entity.
Independence shall be required at least during both the period covered by the financial statements to be audited and the period during which the statutory audit is carried out.
The réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms) and the audit firms shall take all reasonable steps to ensure that, when carrying out a statutory audit, their independence is not affected by any existing or potential conflict of interest or business or other direct or indirect relationship involving the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm carrying out the statutory audit and, where appropriate, his, her or its network, managers, auditors, employees, any other natural persons whose services are placed at the disposal or under the control of the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm, or any person directly or indirectly linked to the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm by control.
The réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm shall not carry out a statutory audit if there is any threat of self-review, self-interest, advocacy, familiarity or intimidation created by financial, personal, business, employment or other relationships between:
the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm), the audit firm, his, her or its network, and any natural person in a position to influence the outcome of the statutory audit, and
the audited entity,
as a result of which an objective, reasonable and informed third party, taking into account the safeguards applied, would conclude that the independence of the réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the audit firm is compromised.” [AL/Article 20(1)].
Public Interest Entities
Provisions of the paragraph R400.22 are replaced by the following provisions:
“For the purposes of this Part, a firm shall treat an entity as a public interest entity when it falls within the definition laid down in article 1 (20) of the Law of 23 July 2016 concerning the audit profession.”
Provisions of paragraphs 400.22 A1, R400.23, 400.23A1, 400.23 A2 and 400.24 A1 are repealed.
Public Disclosure – Application of Independence Requirements for Public Interest Entities
Provisions of paragraph R400.26 are repealed.
Related Entities
Provisions of the paragraph R400.27 are replaced by the following provisions:
“As defined, an audit client that is a publicly traded entity includes all of its related entities. For all other entities, references to an audit client in this Part include related entities over which the client has direct or indirect control. When the audit team knows, or has reason to believe, that a relationship or circumstance involving any other related entity of the client is relevant to the evaluation of the firm’s independence from the client, the audit team shall include that related entity when identifying, evaluating and addressing threats to independence.”
Mergers and acquisitions
When a Client Merger Creates a Threat
In paragraph R400.73 (a), the deadline of six months is shortened to three months [AL/Article 20(6)].
SECTION 410
FEES
Requirements
Level of Audit Fees
Paragraph R410.6 and R410.9 are completed as follows:
“The fees for statutory audit cannot be influenced or determined by the provision of additional services to the audited entity and cannot be based on any form of contingency.” [AL/Article 27]
Total Fees – Proportion of Fees for Services Other than Audit to Audit Fee – Cap of 70% for non-audit services
For Audit Clients that are Public-Interest Entities, paragraph 410.11A1 to A3 are replaced by the following provisions:
“When the réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) provides to the audited entity, its parent undertaking or its controlled undertakings, for a period of three or more consecutive financial years, non-audit services other than those referred to in Article 5(1) of Regulation (EU) No 537/2014, the total fees for such services shall be limited to no more than 70 % of the average of the fees paid in the last three consecutive financial years for the statutory audit(s) of the audited entity and, where applicable, of its parent undertaking, of its controlled undertakings and of the consolidated financial statements of that group of undertakings.
For the purposes of the limits specified above, non-audit services (other than those referred to in Article 5(1) of Regulation (EU) No 537/2014) required by Union or Luxembourg legislation shall be excluded.
On reasoned request, the CSSF may exceptionally relieve the réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) from the obligation to comply with the limits set in the first subparagraph of this paragraph for a maximum period of two financial years”. [AR/Article 4(2) and AL/Article 49]
Total Fees – Fee Dependency
Audit Clients that are Public-Interest Entities
Provisions of paragraph R410.18 are replaced by the following provision:
“When the total fees received from a public-interest entity in each of the last three consecutive financial years are more than 15 % of the total fees received by the réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or, where applicable, by the group auditor carrying out the statutory audit, in each of those financial years, such a réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or a cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or, as the case may be, group auditor, shall disclose that fact to the audit committee and discuss with the audit committee the threats to their independence and the safeguards applied to mitigate those threats. The audit committee shall consider whether the audit engagement should be subject to an engagement quality control review by another statutory auditor or audit firm prior to the issuance of the audit report”. [AR/Article 4(3)]
Provisions of paragraph R410.20, R410.21 and 410.21 A1 are replaced by the following provision:
“Where the fees received from such a public-interest entity continue to exceed 15% of the total fees received by such the réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or, as the case may be, by a group auditor carrying out the statutory audit, the audit committee shall decide on the basis of objective grounds whether the réviseur d'entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor) or the cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or the group auditor, of such an entity or group of entities may continue to carry out the statutory audit for an additional period which shall not, in any case, exceed two years.”
Transparency of Information Regarding Fees for Audit Client that are Public Interest Entities
Communication About Fee-related Information with Those Charged with Governance
Fee Dependency
Provisions of paragraphs R410.28 are repealed.
Public Disclosure of Fee-related Information
Provisions of paragraph R410.30 are replaced by the following provision:
"If laws and regulations do not require an audit client to disclose audit fees, fees for services other than audit paid or payable to the firm, the firm shall discuss with those charged with governance of an audit client that is a public interest entity:
The benefit to the client’s stakeholders of the client making such disclosures that are not required by laws and regulations in a manner deemed appropriate, taking into account the timing and accessibility of the information; and
The information that might enhance the users’ understanding of the fees paid or payable and their impact on the firm’s independence.”
Provisions of paragraph R410.31 are replaced by the following provision:
“After the discussion with those charged with governance as set out in paragraph R410.30, to the extent that the audit client that is a public interest entity does not make the relevant disclosure, subject to paragraph R410.32, the firm shall publicly disclose:
Fees paid or payable to the firm for the audit of the financial statements on which the firm expresses an opinion;
Fees, other than those disclosed under (a), charged to the client for the provision of services by the firm during the period covered by the financial statements on which the firm expresses an opinion. For this purpose, such fees shall only include fees charged to the client and its related entities over which the client has direct or indirect control that are consolidated in the financial statements on which the firm will express an opinion;
Any fees, other than those disclosed under (a) and (b), charged to any other related entities over which the audit client has direct or indirect control for the provision of services by the firm when the firm knows, or has reason to believe, that such fees are relevant to the evaluation of the firm’s independence.”
SECTION 420
GIFTS AND HOSPITALITY
Requirements
Paragraph R420.3 is completed as follows:
“The réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms), the audit firms, their key audit partners, their employees, and any other natural person whose services are placed at the disposal or under the control of such réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm and who is directly involved in statutory audit activities, and persons closely associated with them within the meaning of Article 3(1) point 26 of Regulation (EU) N° 596/2014 of the European Parliament and the council on market abuse of 16 April 2014 (market abuse regulation), shall not solicit or accept pecuniary and non-pecuniary gifts or favours from the audited entity or any entity related to an audited entity unless an objective, reasonable and informed third party would consider the value thereof as trivial or inconsequential.” [AL/Article 20(5)]
SECTION 510
FINANCIAL INTERESTS
Requirements
Financial Interests – Other Circumstances
Provisions of paragraph 510.10 A1 to 510.10 A12 are replaced by the following provision:
“The réviseurs d’entreprises agréés (approved statutory auditors), the cabinets de révision agréés (approved audit firms), the audit firms, their key audit partners, their employees, and any other natural person whose services are placed at the disposal or under the control of such réviseur d’entreprises agréé (approved statutory auditor), cabinet de révision agréé (approved audit firm) or audit firm and who is directly involved in statutory audit activities, and persons closely associated with them within the meaning of Article 3(1) point 26 of Regulation (EU) N° 596/2014 of the European Parliament and the council on market abuse of 16 April 2014 (market abuse regulation):