Annexe 3
Luxembourg guidelines on the auditors’ involvement on financial statements in European Single Electronic Format (ESEF)
(effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after December 15, 2020)
Objective
The European Commission Interpretative Communication 2020/C379/01 states that Union law requires statutory auditors (hereafter “auditors”) to provide an audit opinion on whether the financial statements included in the annual financial reports comply with the relevant statutory requirements laid down in the ESEF Delegated Regulation, i.e. with the provisions of the ESEF Delegated Regulation that apply to financial statements.
In the absence of auditing standard(s) dealing specifically with ESEF reporting applicable in the whole European Union, the objectives of these guidelines are to describe the expectations of the CSSF regarding:
the procedures to be performed by the auditors to assess whether the financial statements included in the annual financial report comply with the ESEF requirements,
the consequences of any misstatements identified by the auditors, and
the form and content of the audit report regarding whether the financial statements comply with the ESEF requirements.
These guidelines highlight specifications to be complied with by auditors in addition to the provisions of auditing standards. The guidelines refer to and do not replace the other requirements on auditing and ethics, including independence, applicable to auditors in Luxembourg.
Procedures to be performed by auditors on financial statements in ESEF
I - Planning of the auditors’ work
The auditors shall plan the procedures to be performed considering the following aspects:
the characteristics of the financial statements prepared in ESEF format,
the deadlines to be met for carrying out the procedures on financial statements in ESEF, and
the process put in place by the entity to prepare the financial statements in ESEF (ref. paragraph 2).
II - Understanding the process for preparing the financial statements in ESEF and related controls
Regarding the preparation of the financial statements in ESEF, the auditors shall obtain an understanding, in particular, of the following:
the process for preparing the financial statements in ESEF including the use of technical (for example IT tools) and human resources and whether the entity outsources partially or totally this preparation to a service provider or uses a management’s expert, and
the controls designed and implemented by the entity to prevent, detect or correct misstatements in the preparation of the financial statements in ESEF.
III - Procedures related to the XHTML format
The auditors shall verify that all financial statements included in the annual financial report are prepared in XHTML format.
In cases where the entity provides financial statements that are not yet prepared in accordance with the ESEF requirements to the auditors for the audit purposes and, later on, provides the financial statements in ESEF, the auditors shall check the reconciliation between those two sets of information (financial statements in XHTML and audited version) to verify their full alignment.
IV - Procedures related to the marking up
The auditors shall perform procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence that the requirements on marking up defined by the ESEF Delegated Regulation have been complied with.
Materiality
The auditors shall use an appropriate materiality level when:
planning and determining the extent of procedures to be performed on marked-up information specified in paragraph 10,
evaluating the effect of identified misstatements pursuant to procedures on marked-up information, and
forming the opinion to be included in the audit report regarding the compliance of the marked-up information with the ESEF requirements.
In determining the materiality for the purposes identified above, auditors shall use as a starting point the materiality defined for the audit of financial statements and take into account quantitative and qualitative aspects that result from the specificities of the marked-up information and the needs and expectations users may have regarding marked up information.
Assessment of risks of material misstatement and responses to those risks
The auditors shall identify and assess the risks of material misstatement in the financial statements presented in ESEF taking into account:
the internal control elements relevant for the preparation of financial statements in ESEF, and
the risks of incompleteness and inaccuracy attached to the marked-up information.
The auditors shall verify that all numbers referred to in Annex II paragraph 1 of the ESEF Delegated Regulation have been marked-up.
For information required to be marked-up according to ESEF Delegated Regulation or for voluntary mark-ups, the auditors shall verify that:
the XBRL mark-up language is used,
the elements of the core taxonomy (specified in Annex VI of the ESEF Delegated Regulation) with the closest accounting meaning are used, unless an extension taxonomy element is created, and
extension taxonomy elements created, if any, comply with Annex IV of the ESEF Delegated Regulation, and
the mark-ups comply with the common rules on mark-ups set out in Annex III (on applicable Inline XBRL specifications) and Annex IV (on the marking up and filing rules) of the ESEF Delegated Regulation.
The mark-ups to be checked according to paragraph 10 shall be selected depending on the risks of material misstatement assessed by the auditors. The auditors may decide to rely, to a certain extent, on relevant controls put in place by the entity, after having obtained sufficient and appropriate evidence on the operating effectiveness of the relevant controls to reduce the extent of substantive procedures.
V - Reporting on compliance with ESEF in the audit report
After performance of the procedures and communication with management and those charged with governance, the auditors shall consider the implications of material misstatements or non-compliance, if any, identified on the audit report.
The audit report shall include:
An opinion on whether the presentation of the financial statements included in the annual financial report:
either complies, in all material aspects, with the ESEF,
either complies with the ESEF, with the exception of material misstatement (s) or non-compliance clearly explained in a specific paragraph and mentioned in the opinion,
either does not comply with the ESEF because of the pervasive effect of material misstatement(s) or non-compliance clearly explained in a specific paragraph and mentioned in the opinion,
or a statement of the auditors’ inability to conclude on the compliance of the presentation of the financial statements in ESEF, in cases where the auditors were unable to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence in this regard. The auditors shall provide the reasons for this inability in the audit report.
VI – Other aspects
Independence
When performing procedures on financial statements in ESEF, the auditors shall remain alert to independence rules applicable and shall not perform any non-audit service prohibited under Article 5 of the Regulation (EU) n°537/2017 of the European Parliament and the Council. The auditors shall also remain alert to any self-review threats related to ESEF.
Engagement letter
The auditors shall include specific arrangements in relation to ESEF in the engagement letter.
Use of an expert
When the auditors decide to use the work of an expert, the provisions on the use of experts for an audit of financial statements shall apply equally in this regard.
Communication
Before issuing the audit report, the auditors shall communicate to management and, where appropriate, those charged with governance, any misstatements identified or non-compliance, other than those that are clearly trivial.
Written representation
The auditors shall request specific provisions in relation to ESEF in the written representation. The auditors may determine that it is appropriate to request specific written representation from management to cover specificities of ESEF, or to include such specificities in the written representation.
Documentation
General provisions for documentation in an audit of financial statements shall apply to procedures performed on financial statements in ESEF.