Recital 43, Regulation (EU) 2024/3011

In force

Transfer of criminal proceedings should not be refused on grounds other than those provided for in this Regulation. For the transfer of criminal proceedings to be accepted, prosecution of the facts underlying the criminal proceedings that are subject to the transfer should be possible in the requested State. The requested authority should refuse the transfer of criminal proceedings if the conduct for which transfer is sought is not a criminal offence in the requested State, or if the requested State does not have jurisdiction over that criminal offence, unless it exercises jurisdiction provided for under this Regulation. The requested authority should also refuse the transfer of criminal proceedings if the conditions for prosecuting the criminal offence in the requested State are not fulfilled. This could be the case, for example, if a complaint by the victim, which is necessary for prosecuting the criminal offence in the requested State, has not been filed in time, or where, because of the death or insanity of the suspect or accused person, prosecution has become impossible pursuant to the national law of the requested State. Furthermore, the requested authority should refuse the transfer of criminal proceedings if there are other impediments to prosecution in the requested State. The requested authority should be able to refuse a transfer of criminal proceedings if the suspect or accused person benefits from a privilege or immunity in accordance with the national law of the requested State, for example in relation to certain categories of persons, such as diplomats, or specifically protected relationships, such as lawyer-client privilege, or if the requested authority believes that such transfer is not justified by the interests of efficient and proper administration of justice, for instance because none of the criteria for requesting a transfer of criminal proceedings are met, or if the request form for the transfer of criminal proceedings is incomplete or manifestly incorrect and has not been completed or corrected by the requesting authority, thus meaning the requested authority does not have the necessary information to assess the request for the transfer of criminal proceedings. The requested authority should also be able to refuse the request if the conduct is not a criminal offence at the place where it was committed and the requested State has no original jurisdiction to investigate and prosecute such offence. That ground for refusal takes into account the principle of territoriality, meaning that the requested State should be able to refuse the transfer of criminal proceedings in cases where the alleged criminal offence, which is committed outside the territory of the requesting State, is not a criminal offence at the place where it was committed, and the national law of the requested State does not authorise the prosecution of such offences where committed outside its territory. For the purposes of this Regulation, ‘original jurisdiction’ is the jurisdiction which is already provided for by national law and does not derive from this Regulation.