127 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › Existence of aid in the case of State guarantees, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394

In forcesince 7 Oct 2019

The Greek authorities argued that there was no benefit or State resources involved since the State guarantees were given on the basis of collaterals that secured the interests of the State in full. According to the Greek authorities, the State was obliged to make use of the rights granted by the collaterals, if the beneficiaries had failed to pay back the loans. This line of argumentation cannot be accepted. First, as stated in the opening decision (see recital 52 of the present Decision), the Commission did not accept the same arguments made by the Greek authorities in its Decision 2012/320/EU and the Court upheld that reasoning [See judgment of the General Court of 9 April 2014, Greece v Commission, Case T-150/12, EU:T:2014:191, paragraphs 82-85, 98.]. In their letter of 23 September 2016, the Greek authorities referred to the same Ministerial Decision No 2/478/0025/4.1.2006 (GG II 16/13.1.2006), as they did in that older case, in order to suggest that the tax authorities are obliged to embark on all necessary legal actions in order to collect the amounts paid by the State under the guarantee. However, as with the older case the only reference to Ministerial Decision No 2/478/0025/4.1.2006 (GG II 16/13.1.2006) in the legal basis in question was to provide for the actions that banks needed to undertake in order to activate the State guarantee. Indeed, no provision in the legal basis of the schemes provided for an automatic activation of the collateral agreements in cases where the State guarantees were paid. Moreover, the collaterals were not required in all cases and it remains unclear whether they had to secure the full amount of the loan in all cases. Lastly, the existence of collaterals cannot alter the assessment that there was a benefit due to the fact that the beneficiaries did not pay any premium for the risk undertaken by the State through the State guarantee.

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (septième chambre) du 9 avril 2014. République hellénique contre Commission européenne.Decision

    9 Apr 2014 · 62012TJ0150

  • Decision_act (EU) 2012/320Law